Abstract
This study evaluates the environmental performance of electrochemically-based soda (Na2CO3) production processes based on sodium chloride (NaCl) and anthropogenic carbon dioxide (CO2) as feedstocks, employing a comparative cradle-to-gate life cycle assessment. Since a detailed environmental comparison of established and emerging Na2CO3 production routes is currently missing in the literature, this study aims to provide a systematic life cycle performance comparison to support the evaluation of alternative soda production pathways. Alternative production processes based on electrodialysis or chlor-alkali electrolysis were assumed to offer advantages over the state-of-the-art Solvay process, such as a lower carbon footprint, the absence of CaCl2 emissions, and the generation of economically valuable by-products, namely HCl, H2 and Cl2. All processes were modeled in openLCA using ecoinvent 3.11 for optimistic and pessimistic 2050 scenarios, assuming predominantly renewable energy mixes for electricity and process heat provided either by natural gas or geothermal energy. The results show that carbon-neutral or carbon-negative Na2CO3 production (−0.04 ± 0.03 kg CO2 eq per kg Na2CO3 including by-products with mass allocation) is achievable when the chlor-alkali-based process is combined with geothermal energy. Even with conventional process steam from natural gas, the carbon footprint of the chlor-alkali-based process remains about 95% lower than that of the Solvay process. In contrast, the electrodialysis-based process achieves a lower carbon footprint than the Solvay process only when geothermal heat supply is applied. Furthermore, all electrochemically-based processes exhibit substantially reduced chloride emissions compared to the Solvay process, demonstrating the potential for more environmentally friendly Na2CO3 production.

This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit: