Can artificial intelligence pass the Fellowship of the Royal College of Radiologists examination? Multi-reader diagnostic accuracy study
Open Access
Abstract
Objective To determine whether an artificial intelligence candidate could pass the rapid (radiographic) reporting component of the Fellowship of the Royal College of Radiologists (FRCR) examination. Design Prospective multi-reader diagnostic accuracy study. Setting United Kingdom. Participants One artificial intelligence candidate (Smarturgences, Milvue) and 26 radiologists who had passed the FRCR examination in the preceding 12 months. Main outcome measures Accuracy and pass rate of the artificial intelligence compared with radiologists across 10 mock FRCR rapid reporting examinations (each examination containing 30 radiographs, requiring 90% accuracy rate to pass). Results When non-interpretable images were excluded from the analysis, the artificial intelligence candidate achieved an average overall accuracy of 79.5% (95% confidence interval 74.1% to 84.3%) and passed two of 10 mock FRCR examinations. The average radiologist achieved an average accuracy of 84.8% (76.1-91.9%) and passed four of 10 mock examinations. The sensitivity for the artificial intelligence was 83.6% (95% confidence interval 76.2% to 89.4%) and the specificity was 75.2% (66.7% to 82.5%), compared with summary estimates across all radiologists of 84.1% (81.0% to 87.0%) and 87.3% (85.0% to 89.3%). Across 148/300 radiographs that were correctly interpreted by >90% of radiologists, the artificial intelligence candidate was incorrect in 14/148 (9%). In 20/300 radiographs that most (>50%) radiologists interpreted incorrectly, the artificial intelligence candidate was correct in 10/20 (50%). Most imaging pitfalls related to interpretation of musculoskeletal rather than chest radiographs. Conclusions When special dispensation for the artificial intelligence candidate was provided (that is, exclusion of non-interpretable images), the artificial intelligence candidate was able to pass two of 10 mock examinations. Potential exists for the artificial intelligence candidate to improve its radiographic interpretation skills by focusing on musculoskeletal cases and learning to interpret radiographs of the axial skeleton and abdomen that are currently considered “non-interpretable.”Keywords
Funding Information
- National Institute for Health and Care Research
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Improving Radiographic Fracture Recognition Performance and Efficiency Using Artificial IntelligenceRadiology, 2022
- Can AI distinguish a bone radiograph from photos of flowers or cars? Evaluation of bone age deep learning model on inappropriate data inputsSkeletal Radiology, 2021
- Effect of a comprehensive deep-learning model on the accuracy of chest x-ray interpretation by radiologists: a retrospective, multireader multicase studyThe Lancet Digital Health, 2021
- Diagnostic accuracy of deep learning in medical imaging: a systematic review and meta-analysisnpj Digital Medicine, 2021
- Artificial intelligence: Who is responsible for the diagnosis?La radiologia medica, 2020
- The Fellowship of the Royal College of Radiologists (FRCR) examination: a review of the evidenceClinical Radiology, 2018
- Demystification of AI-driven medical image interpretation: past, present and futureEuropean Radiology, 2018
- Machine Learning: Discovering the Future of Medical ImagingJournal of Digital Imaging, 2017
- Fitting Linear Mixed-Effects Models Usinglme42015
- Radiology training in United Kingdom: current status2014