Patient-specific finite element estimated femur strength as a predictor of the risk of hip fracture: the effect of methodological determinants
Authors:
Open Access
- 23 April 2016
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Osteoporosis International
- Vol. 27 (9) , 2815-2822
Abstract
Summary A finite element modelling pipeline was adopted to predict femur strength in a retrospective cohort of 100 women. The effects of the imaging protocol and the meshing technique on the ability of the femur strength to classify the fracture and the control groups were analysed. Introduction The clinical standard to estimate the risk of osteoporotic hip fracture is based on the areal bone mineral density (aBMD). A few retrospective studies have concluded that finite element (FE)-based femoral strength is a better classifier of fracture and control groups than the aBMD, while others could not find significant differences. We investigated the effect of the imaging protocol and of the FE modelling techniques on the discriminatory power of femoral strength. Methods A retrospective cohort of 100 post-menopausal women (50 with hip fracture, 50 controls) was examined. Each subject received a dual-energy absorptiometry (DXA) exam and a computed tomography (CT) scan of the proximal femur region. Each case was modelled a number of times, using different modelling pipelines, and the results were compared in terms of accuracy in discriminating the fracture and the control cases. The baseline pipeline involved local anatomical orientation and mesh morphing. Revised pipelines involved global anatomical orientation using a full-femur atlas registration and an optimised meshing algorithm. Minimum physiological (MPhyS) and pathological (MPatS) strengths were estimated for each subject. Area under the receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve (AUC) was calculated to compare the ability of MPhyS, MPatS and aBMD to classify the control and the cases. Results Differences in the modelling protocol were found to considerably affect the accuracy of the FE predictors. For the most optimised protocol, logistic regression showed aBMDNeck, MPhyS and MPatS to be significantly associated with the facture status, with AUC of 0.75, 0.75 and 0.79, respectively. Conclusion The study emphasized the necessity of modelling the whole femur anatomy to develop a robust FE-based tool for hip fracture risk assessment. FE-strength performed only slightly better than the aBMD in discriminating the fracture and control cases. Differences between the published studies can be explained in terms of differences in the modelling protocol and cohort design.Keywords
Funding Information
- Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EP/K03877X/1)
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- Patient-Specific Finite-Element Analyses of the Proximal Femur with Orthotropic Material Properties Validated by ExperimentsJournal of Biomechanical Engineering, 2011
- Male–female differences in the association between incident hip fracture and proximal femoral strength: A finite element analysis studyBone, 2011
- Evaluation of the generality and accuracy of a new mesh morphing procedure for the human femurMedical Engineering & Physics, 2010
- Bias in odds ratios by logistic regression modelling and sample sizeBMC Medical Research Methodology, 2009
- Finite Element Analysis of the Proximal Femur and Hip Fracture Risk in Older MenJournal of Bone and Mineral Research, 2009
- Epidemiology of osteoporosisBest Practice & Research Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism, 2008
- Subject-specific finite element models implementing a maximum principal strain criterion are able to estimate failure risk and fracture location on human femurs tested in vitroJournal of Biomechanics, 2008
- Predictive Value of BMD for Hip and Other FracturesJournal of Bone and Mineral Research, 2005
- Trabecular bone modulus–density relationships depend on anatomic siteJournal of Biomechanics, 2003
- Publication and related bias in meta-analysisJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2000