Abstract
In this paper, the meaning and processing of the German conditional connectives (CCs) such aswenn‘if’ andnur wenn‘only if’ are investigated. In Experiment 1, participants read short scenarios containing a conditional sentence (i.e., If P, Q.) withwenn/nur wenn‘if/only if’ and a confirmed or negated antecedent (i.e., P/not-P), and subsequently completed the final sentence about Q (with or without negation). In Experiment 2, participants rated the truth or falsity of the consequent Q after reading a conditional sentence withwennornur wennand a confirmed or negated antecedent (i.e., If P, Q. P/not-P. // Therefore, Q?). Both experiments showed that neitherwennnornur wennwere interpreted as biconditional CCs. Modus Ponens (If P, Q. P. // Therefore, Q) was validated forwenn, whereas it was not validated in the case ofnur wenn. While Denial of the Antecedent (If P, Q. not-P. // Therefore, not-Q.) was validated in the case ofnur wenn, it was not validated forwenn. The same method was used to testwennvs.unter der Bedingung, dass‘on condition that’ in Experiment 3, andwennvs.vorausgesetzt, dass‘provided that’ in Experiment 4. Experiment 5, using Affirmation of the Consequent (If P, Q. Q. // Therefore, P.) to testwennvs.nur wennreplicated the results of Experiment 2. Taken together, the results show that in German,unter der Bedingung, dassis the most likely candidate of biconditional CCs whereas all others are not biconditional. The findings, in particular ofnur wennnot being semantically biconditional, are discussed based on available formal analyses of conditionals.
Funding Information
  • Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (367088975)
  • Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin

This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit: