Jury decision‐making biases and methods to counter them
- 1 February 2010
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Legal and Criminological Psychology
- Vol. 15 (1) , 133-154
Abstract
Purpose. The objective of this review was to give a broad overview of various biases associated with jury decision making. Specifically we review research on the impact of pretrial publicity, jury instructions, inadmissible evidence, and scientific evidence. This article elucidates various challenges jurors may face across systems around the world and remedies to counter these challenges. Results. After 50 years of scientific research on juries and juror decision making, there are still many gaps in understanding how factors such as pretrial publicity, inadmissible evidence, scientific evidence, and jury instructions influence juries. At the same time the field has developed a level of appreciation for these problems and is making strives toward understanding them. Conclusion. Based on this review some conclusions can be drawn regarding the areas of decision making reviewed. Jury instructions: Research shows that jurors have difficulties in understanding pattern instructions, at the same time we have developed some insights into ways instructions can be rewritten to increase comprehensibility. Inadmissible evidence: We are aware of the cognitive effort involved in attempting to disregard evidence but are at this point unclear on how to eliminate the associated problems. Scientific evidence: Research has illuminated the difficulties jurors have with comprehending scientific evidence. Better education of jurors and judges can help to address this issue. Pretrial publicity: The threats posed by pretrial publicity to the defendant's right to a fair trial are clear. At the same time (save change of venue) there is a need to develop cost‐effective remedies to help overcome media‐induced biases.Keywords
This publication has 64 references indexed in Scilit:
- Jurors' use of probabilistic evidence.Law and Human Behavior, 1996
- The biasing impact of pretrial publicity on juror judgments.Law and Human Behavior, 1994
- Trial complexity: A field investigation of its meaning and its effects.Law and Human Behavior, 1994
- The feasibility and utility of pretrial instruction in the substantive law: A survey of judges.Law and Human Behavior, 1990
- Pretrial publicity, judicial remedies, and jury bias.Law and Human Behavior, 1990
- Instructing jurors: A field experiment with written and preliminary instructions.Law and Human Behavior, 1989
- Free press and fair trial: The role of behavioral research.Law and Human Behavior, 1986
- Decision making in joined criminal trials: The influence of charge similarity, evidence similarity, and limiting instructions.Law and Human Behavior, 1985
- On the inefficacy of limiting instructions: When jurors use prior conviction evidence to decide on guilt.Law and Human Behavior, 1985
- Psychologists as consultants for changes of venue: The use of public opinion surveys.Law and Human Behavior, 1983