Comparison of algorithms for determination of rotation measure and Faraday structure I. 1100 - 1400 MHz
Authors:
- X. H. SunXSX. H. Sun
- L. RudnickLRL. Rudnick
- Takuya AkahoriTATakuya Akahori
- C. S. AndersonCAC. S. Anderson
- M. R. BellMBM. R. Bell
- J. D. BrayJBJ. D. Bray
- J. S. FarnesJFJ. S. Farnes
- S. IdeguchiSIS. Ideguchi
- K. KumazakiKKK. Kumazaki
- T. O'BrienTOT. O'Brien
- S. P. O'SullivanSOS. P. O'Sullivan
- A. M. M. ScaifeASA. M. M. Scaife
Preprint
Abstract
(abridged) We run a Faraday structure determination data challenge to benchmark the currently available algorithms including Faraday synthesis (previously called RM synthesis in the literature), wavelet, compressive sampling and $QU$-fitting. The frequency set is similar to POSSUM/GALFACTS with a 300 MHz bandwidth from 1.1 to 1.4 GHz. We define three figures of merit motivated by the underlying science: a) an average RM weighted by polarized intensity, RMwtd, b) the separation $\Delta\phi$ of two Faraday components and c) the reduced chi-squared. Based on the current test data of signal to noise ratio of about 32, we find that: (1) When only one Faraday thin component is present, most methods perform as expected, with occasional failures where two components are incorrectly found; (2) For two Faraday thin components, QU-fitting routines perform the best, with errors close to the theoretical ones for RMwtd, but with significantly higher errors for $\Delta\phi$. All other methods including standard Faraday synthesis frequently identify only one component when $\Delta\phi$ is below or near the width of the Faraday point spread function; (3) No methods, as currently implemented, work well for Faraday thick components due to the narrow bandwidth; (4) There exist combinations of two Faraday components which produce a large range of acceptable fits and hence large uncertainties in the derived single RMs; in these cases, different RMs lead to the same Q, U behavior, so no method can recover a unique input model.
Keywords
All Related Versions
- Version 1, 2014-09-15, ArXiv
- Published version: The Astronomical Journal, 149 (2), 60.
This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit:
- Improved CLEAN reconstructions for rotation measure synthesis with maximum likelihood estimationAstronomy & Astrophysics, 2013
- Recognizing magnetic structures by present and future radio telescopes with Faraday rotation measure synthesisAstronomy & Astrophysics, 2012
- Faraday synthesisAstronomy & Astrophysics, 2012
- Newλ6 cm andλ11 cm observations of the supernova remnant CTA 1Astronomy & Astrophysics, 2011
- The application of compressive sampling to radio astronomyAstronomy & Astrophysics, 2011
- The Westerbork SINGS surveyAstronomy & Astrophysics, 2010
- Simulated square kilometre array maps from Galactic 3D-emission modelsAstronomy & Astrophysics, 2009
- The Faraday rotation measure synthesis techniqueProceedings of the International Astronomical Union, 2008
- Probing interstellar magnetic fields with Supernova remnantsProceedings of the International Astronomical Union, 2008
- Depolarization and Faraday effects in galaxiesMonthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 1998