Assessing the probability of patients reoffending after discharge from low to medium secure forensic mental health services: An inductive prevention paradox
Authors:
- 1 February 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Health, Risk & Society
- Vol. 15 (1) , 84-102
Abstract
Citizens of developed societies are troubled by those who commit ‘irrational' crimes against the person. Reoffending by ex-patients following their release from secure mental health services triggers particularly intense angst when amplified by media and political scrutiny. Forensic mental health service providers are expected to minimise the occurrence of such transgressions by releasing only those patients who are judged acceptably unlikely to reoffend. However, reoffending probabilities can only be estimated by observing behaviour in secure institutional settings designed specifically to prevent patients from transgressing. The article explores this ‘inductive prevention paradox' which arises when the implementation of measures designed to avoid an adverse event obscures direct observation of what might have happened if prophylaxis had not been attempted. The analysis presented draws on data obtained in 1999–2003 from two qualitative studies in medium to low secure UK institutions, one providing forensic mental health services and the other forensic learning disability services. We explored the views of 56 staff members and 21 patients about risk management in forensic services and undertook additional 25 staff interviews for case studies of the 21 patients. The wider applicability of the inductive prevention paradox will be considered in the Discussion. We argue that the prognostic limitations arising from prevention have been underestimated by policy makers and in official inquiries; and that the prevailing personal risk assessment framework needs to be complemented by greater attention to the environments which patients will be discharged into.Keywords
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- Tools for the job: why relying on risk assessment tools is still a risky businessJournal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 2011
- The utility of the Historical Clinical Risk -20 Scale as a predictor of outcomes in decisions to transfer patients from high to lower levels of security-A UK perspectiveBMC Psychiatry, 2010
- Forensic nurses' perceptions of labels of mental illness and personality disorder: clinical versus management issuesJournal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 2010
- Multidisciplinary Teamwork in a UK Regional Secure Mental Health Unit a Matter for Negotiation?Social Theory & Health, 2007
- Is the PCL-R Really the “Unparalleled” Measure of Offender Risk?Criminal Justice and Behavior, 2002
- Forensic mental healthThe British Journal of Psychiatry, 2000
- Prisoners' Perspectives on Strategies for ReleaseJournal of Offender Rehabilitation, 1996
- THE FALSE PROMISES OF RISK ANALYSISRatio, 1993
- On the social psychology of the psychological experiment: With particular reference to demand characteristics and their implications.American Psychologist, 1962
- Ecological Correlations and the Behavior of IndividualsAmerican Sociological Review, 1950