From Reuse Potential to Reuse Success: Developing and Applying the Adaptive Reuse Success Index for Industrial Heritage Buildings
Open Access
Abstract
Adaptive reuse is widely used to extend the life of heritage and industrial heritage buildings, but its assessment remains divided between reuse potential, alternative selection, sustainability, post-occupancy performance, and conservation-based evaluation. This article develops the Adaptive Reuse Success Index (ARSI), a literature-derived framework for assessing adaptive reuse success as a multidimensional architectural condition. The framework was developed through a structured framework-development review and full-text coding of 31 studies, supported by a documented Scopus audit trail. Assessment concepts were extracted, normalized into codes, synthesized into themes, and translated into measurable indicators. ARSI comprises eight dimensions: Heritage Conservation Value, Functional Compatibility, Technical/Physical Performance, Environmental/Circular Performance, Economic Viability, Social and Community Value, Urban Integration and Regeneration, and Governance and Implementation Capacity. These dimensions are operationalized through a 40-indicator matrix with equal-weight scoring, literature-prominence sensitivity weighting, and non-compensatory safeguards. An illustrative application to Santralistanbul shows that the framework can separate strong heritage, functional, and urban performance from weaker or insufficiently evidenced social, economic, technical, and governance conditions. ARSI is proposed as an initial diagnostic framework rather than a validated universal index, offering a structured basis for comparative assessment and post-reuse evaluation in industrial heritage contexts.Keywords
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- An integrated assessment framework for adaptive reuse potential of UNESCO heritage buildings based on multisource dataJournal of Cultural Heritage, 2026
- Abandoned industrial heritage: From waste to resource. Which evaluation tools to evaluate this circular process?Journal of Cultural Heritage, 2025
- Unlocking multiple potentials: a data-driven framework for adaptive reuse of industrial heritage in Changzhou, ChinaJournal of Asian Architecture and Building Engineering, 2025
- Assessing the environmental benefits of adaptive reuse in historical buildings. A case study of a life cycle assessment approachSustainable Environment, 2024
- Historical heritage–MultiCriteria Decision Method (H-MCDM) to prioritize intervention strategies for the adaptive reuse of valuable architectural assetsMethodsX, 2023
- Adaptive Reuse of Heritage Buildings: From a Literature Review to a Model of PracticeThe Historic Environment: Policy & Practice, 2022
- Adaptability evaluation of historic buildings as an approach to propose adaptive reuse strategies based on complex adaptive system theoryJournal of Cultural Heritage, 2021
- Literature review as a research methodology: An overview and guidelinesJournal of Business Research, 2019
- Towards the comprehensive and systematic assessment of the adaptive reuse of Islamic architectural heritage in CairoJournal of Cultural Heritage Management and Sustainable Development, 2015
- Assessment of the compatibility of new uses for heritage buildings: The example of Alexandria National Museum, Alexandria, EgyptJournal of Cultural Heritage, 2014