The speed-to-scrutiny paradox in social media-driven HRM: evidence from Albania
- 29 October 2026
- journal article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Employee Relations: The International Journal
- p. 1-27
Abstract
Purpose: This study examines the dual role of social media in human resource management (HRM), highlighting how digital platforms simultaneously enhance recruitment efficiency while intensifying ethical, legal and governance challenges. Focusing on Albania as a transition economy, the study explores how HR professionals navigate the tension between speed, reach and visibility, and the requirements of fairness, privacy and regulatory compliance. Design/methodology/approach: Drawing on McFarland and Ployhart's (2015) discrete ambient stimuli (DAS) framework, complemented by signalling theory, the study adopts a qualitative multi-case design based on 12 semi-structured key-informant interviews with HR decision-makers in 12 organisations, grouped by level of recruitment formalisation, across banking, technology, consulting, microfinance and public administration. Data were analysed thematically using a codebook that separates platform properties (DAS), recruiter interpretation of candidate signals and HR practices, combining theory-driven coding with inductive insights from the Albanian context. Findings: The findings show that social media transform recruitment by enhancing accessibility, immediacy and targeting precision, enabling faster and more cost-effective talent acquisition. However, these efficiencies are accompanied by heightened exposure to privacy risks, data permanence and evaluative bias. The study identifies a “speed-to-scrutiny” paradox, whereby the same platform characteristics that accelerate recruitment also expand the scope of candidate evaluation and ethical vulnerability. In response, HR professionals develop emergent governance practices, including General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR)-aligned policies, “minimum data” principles and ethical training, although implementation remains uneven across organisations. Originality/value: This study extends the DAS framework to a post-socialist context, integrating it with signalling theory to specify how platform-specific stimuli, as contextual antecedents, alter the candidate signals on which recruiters rely. It identifies institutional formalisation as a boundary condition that moderates whether platform signals supplement or substitute for formal screening. It advances the concept of the speed-to-scrutiny paradox as a core mechanism linking digital efficiency with ethical complexity in HRM, and offers context-sensitive insights into how organisations develop hybrid governance practices in emerging digital labour markets.Keywords
This publication has 34 references indexed in Scilit:
- Trust and procedural justice mediate the effects of AI hiring on organizational attraction and intent to applyDiscover Artificial Intelligence, 2025
- How applicants respond to the recruitment process: unravelling temporal patterns of fairness perceptionsEuropean Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology, 2024
- Applicant reactions to social media assessment: A review and conceptual frameworkHuman Resource Management Review, 2022
- The future of employee developmentHuman Resource Management Review, 2021
- Attracting applicants through the organization's social media page: Signaling employer brand personalityJournal of Vocational Behavior, 2019
- Recruiting with ethics in an online era: Integrating corporate social responsibility with social media to predict organizational attractivenessJournal of Vocational Behavior, 2018
- Technology adoption in employee recruitment: The case of social media in Central and Eastern EuropeComputers in Human Behavior, 2016
- Social media: A contextual framework to guide research and practice.Journal of Applied Psychology, 2015
- Social Media Use in Organizations: Exploring the Affordances of Visibility, Editability, Persistence, and AssociationAnnals of the International Communication Association, 2013
- Personnel selection as a signaling game.Journal of Applied Psychology, 2012