‘For the most part it works’: Exploring how authors navigate peer review feedback
- 4 September 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 57 (2) , 151-160
Abstract
Background: Peer review aims to provide meaningful feedback to research authors so that they may improve their work, and yet it constitutes a particularly challenging context for the exchange of feedback. We explore how research authors navigate the process of interpreting and responding to peer review feedback, in order to elaborate how feedback functions when some of the conditions thought to be necessary for it to be effective are not met. Methods: Using constructivist grounded theory methodology, we interviewed 17 recently published health professions education researchers about their experiences with the peer review process. Data collection and analysis were concurrent and iterative. We used constant comparison to identify themes and to develop a conceptual model of how feedback functions in this setting. Results: Although participants expressed faith in peer review, they acknowledged that the process was emotionally trying and raised concerns about its consistency and credibility. These potential threats were mitigated by factors including time, team support, experience and the exercise of autonomy. Additionally, the perceived engagement of reviewers and the cultural norms and expectations surrounding the process strengthened authors' willingness and capacity to respond productively. Our analysis suggests a model of feedback within which its perceived usefulness turns on the balance of threats and countermeasures. Conclusions: Feedback is a balancing act. Although threats to the productive uptake of peer review feedback abound, these threats may be neutralised by a range of countermeasures. Among these, opportunities for autonomy and cultural normalisation of both the professional responsibility to engage with feedback and the challenge of doing so may be especially influential and may have implications beyond the peer review setting.Keywords
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- The “Educational Alliance” as a Framework for Reconceptualizing Feedback in Medical EducationAcademic Medicine, 2015
- Writing Cover Letters That Address Instructor Feedback Improves Final Papers in a Research Methods CourseTeaching of Psychology, 2014
- Use of politeness strategies in signed open peer reviewJournal of the Association for Information Science and Technology, 2014
- Learning culture and feedback: an international study of medical athletes and musiciansMedical Education, 2014
- Beyond individualism: professional culture and its influence on feedbackMedical Education, 2013
- Student perceptions of assessment and feedback in longitudinal integrated clerkshipsMedical Education, 2013
- Feedback, the various tasks of the doctor, and the feedforward alternativeMedical Education, 2010
- The reviewer is always right: peer review of research in Medical EducationMedical Education, 2008
- Author Perception of Peer ReviewObstetrics & Gynecology, 2008
- Double-blind review favours increased representation of female authorsTrends in Ecology & Evolution, 2008