When is it appropriate to reprimand a norm violation? The roles of anger, behavioral consequences, violation severity, and social distance
Authors:
Open Access
- 1 January 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Judgment and Decision Making
- Vol. 12 (4) , 396-407
Abstract
Experiments on economic games typically fail to find positive reputational effects of using peer punishment of selfish behavior in social dilemmas. Theorists had expected positive reputational effects because of the potentially beneficial consequences that punishment may have on norm violators’ behavior. Going beyond the game-theoretic paradigm, we used vignettes to study how various social factors influence approval ratings of a peer who reprimands a violator of a group-beneficial norm. We found that ratings declined when punishers showed anger, and this effect was mediated by perceived aggressiveness. Thus the same emotions that motivate peer punishers may make them come across as aggressive, to the detriment of their reputation. However, the negative effect of showing anger disappeared when the norm violation was sufficiently severe. Ratings of punishers were also influenced by social distance, such that it is less appropriate for a stranger than a friend to reprimand a violator. In sum, peer punisher ratings were very high for a friend reprimanding a severe norm violation, but particularly poor for a stranger showing anger at a mild norm violation. We found no effect on ratings of whether the reprimand had the beneficial consequence of changing the violator’s behavior. Our findings provide insight into how peer punishers can avoid negative reputational effects. They also point to the importance of going beyond economic games when studying peer punishment.Keywords
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- The evolution of punishmentBiology & Philosophy, 2012
- Emotion and the construal of social situations: Inferences of cooperation versus competition from expressions of anger, happiness, and disappointmentCognition and Emotion, 2012
- The Role of Probability of Detection in Judgments of PunishmentJournal of Legal Analysis, 2009
- Descriptive norms, prescriptive norms, and social control: An intercultural comparison of people's reactions to uncivil behaviorsEuropean Journal of Social Psychology, 2009
- The Relationship Between Perceived Violation of Social Norms and Social Control: Situational Factors Influencing the Reaction to DevianceJournal of Applied Social Psychology, 2005
- Why People Punish DefectorsJournal of Theoretical Biology, 2001
- Assessing Punitive Damages (With Notes on Cognition and Valuation in Law)The Yale Law Journal, 1998
- Nonconsequentialist decisionsBehavioral and Brain Sciences, 1994
- Intuitions about penalties and compensation in the context of tort lawJournal of Risk and Uncertainty, 1993
- Moral Reproach and Moral Action*Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour, 1978