Using residents and experts to evaluate the validity of areal wombling for detecting social boundaries: A small-scale feasibility study
Open Access
- 26 August 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 19 (8) , e0305774
Abstract
Several studies have explored the relationship between socially constructed neighbourhood boundaries (henceforth social boundaries) and ethnic tensions. To measure these relationships, studies have used area-level demographic data to predict the location of social boundaries and their characteristics. The most common approach uses areal wombling to locate neighbouring areas with large differences in residential characteristics. Areas with large differences (or higher boundary values) are used as a proxy for well-defined social boundaries. However, to date, the results of these predictions have never been empirically validated. This article presents results from a simple discrete choice experiment designed to test whether the areal wombling approach to boundary detection produces social boundaries that are recognisable to local residents and experts as such. We conducted a small feasibility trial with residents and experts in Rotherham, England. Our results shows that participants were more likely to recognise boundaries with higher boundary values as local community borders. We end with a discussion on the scalability of the design and suggest future improvements.Keywords
Funding Information
- NordForsk (95193)
- NordForsk (95193)
- University of Sheffield
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Social Frontiers: Estimating the Spatial Boundaries Between Residential Groups and Their Impacts on Crime2021
- The Spatial Structure and Local Experience of Residential SegregationSpatial Demography, 2021
- Both Sides of the Street: Introducing Measures of Physical and Social Boundaries Based on Differences Across Sides of the Street, and Consequences for CrimeJournal of Quantitative Criminology, 2021
- Living on the Edge: Neighborhood Boundaries and the Spatial Dynamics of Violent CrimeDemography, 2018
- Frontiers in Residential Segregation: Understanding Neighbourhood Boundaries and Their ImpactsTijdschrift Voor Economische En Sociale Geografie, 2018
- Mechanical Turk upends social sciencesScience, 2016
- Discrete choice experiments in health economics: a review of the literatureHealth Economics, 2010
- “It Depends on How You Define Integrated”: Neighborhood Boundaries and Racial Integration in a Baltimore Neighborhood1Sociological Forum, 2009
- Subjective Constructions of Neighborhood Boundaries: Lessons from a Qualitative Study of Four NeighborhoodsJournal of Urban Affairs, 2009
- Bayesian Areal Wombling for Geographical Boundary AnalysisGeographical Analysis, 2005