Prevalence of physical violence against people in insecure migration status: A systematic review and meta-analysis
Open Access
- 27 March 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 19 (3) , e0300189
Abstract
Objectives: This study summarised evidence on the prevalence of interpersonal, community and state physical violence against people in insecure migration status. Methods: We conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis of primary studies that estimated prevalence of physical violence against a population in insecure migration status. We searched Embase, Social Policy and Practice, Political Science Complete, SocINDEX and Web of Science Social Sciences Citation Index for reports published from January 2000 until 31 May 2023. Study quality was assessed using an adapted version of the Joanna Briggs assessment tool for cross-sectional studies. Two reviewers carried out screening, data extraction, quality assessment and analysis. Meta-analysis was conducted in Stata 17, using a random effects model and several exploratory subgroup analyses. Results: We retrieved 999 reports and included 31 retrospective cross-sectional studies with 25,997 migrants in insecure status. The prevalence estimate of physical violence was 31.16% (95% CI 25.62–36.70, p < .00). There was no statistically significant difference in the estimates for prevalence of violence for men (35.30%, 95% CI 18.45–52.15, p < .00) and for women (27.78%, 95% CI 21.42–34.15, p < .00). The highest point estimate of prevalence of violence was where insecure status was related to employment (44.40%, 95% CI 18.24–70.57, p < .00), although there were no statistically significant difference in the subgroup analysis. The prevalence of violence for people in undocumented status was not significantly different (29.13%, 95% CI 19.86–38.41, p < .00) than that for refugees and asylum seekers (33.29%, 95% CI 20.99–45.59, p < .00). The prevalence of violence in Asia was 56.01% (95% CI 22.47–89.55, p < .00). Europe had the lowest point prevalence estimate (17.98%, 95% CI 7.36–28.61, p < .00), although the difference was not statistically significant. The prevalence estimate during the migration journey was 32.93% (95% CI 24.98–40.88, p < .00). Intimate partner violence attached to insecure status was estimated at 29.10%, (95% CI 8.37–49.84, p = .01), and state violence at 9.19% (95% CI 6.71–11.68, p < .00). Conclusions: The prevalence of physical violence is a concern among people in a range of insecure migration statuses. Prevalence of violence is not meaningfully higher for people in undocumented status than for people in other types of insecure status. Review registration: PROSPERO (CRD42021268772).Keywords
Funding Information
- UK Prevention Research Partnership (MR-VO49879/1)
This publication has 102 references indexed in Scilit:
- Tortures alleged by migrants in Italy: compatibility and other medicolegal challengesInternational journal of legal medicine, 2021
- Legal geographies of irregular migration: An outlook on immigration detentionPopulation, Space and Place, 2020
- Traumatic Stress Among Sexual and Gender Minority Refugees From the Middle East, North Africa, and Asia Who Fled to the European UnionJournal of Traumatic Stress, 2018
- Symbolic violence and disempowerment as factors in the adverse impact of immigration detention on adult asylum seekers’ mental healthInternational Journal of Public Health, 2018
- From Human Trafficking to Modern Slavery: The Development of Anti-Trafficking Policy in the UKEuropean Journal on Criminal Policy and Research, 2018
- Interpersonal Violence Among Immigrants in PortugalJournal of Immigrant and Minority Health, 2012
- Violence Committed Against Migrants in Transit: Experiences on the Northern Mexican BorderJournal of Immigrant and Minority Health, 2011
- A basic introduction to fixed-effect and random-effects models for meta-analysisResearch Synthesis Methods, 2010
- Development and validation of a new instrument to assess lifetime trauma and victimization historyJournal of Traumatic Stress, 2005
- Assessing for Abuse During PregnancyJAMA, 1992