Modifying the CROPGRO‐Soybean Model to Improve Predictions for the Upper Midwest
Authors:
- 1 March 2004
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Agronomy Journal
- Vol. 96 (2) , 556-564
Abstract
The CROPGRO‐Soybean model has not been extensively evaluated in the upper Midwest. The objective of this project was to determine if modifications of the CROPGRO‐Soybean model would improve predictions in the upper Midwest using three cultivars in five management systems and two planting dates from 1997 to 2000. Version 3.5 of the model was compared with 1998 data and found to underestimate total biomass and grain yield at harvest. Changes in temperature function on leaf expansion rate and base temperature for pod addition improved model performance and decreased root mean square error (RMSE) for biomass at harvest and grain yield from 734 to 707 kg ha−1 and from 410 to 362 kg ha−1, respectively. The modified model was then tested with independent data from 1997, 1999, and 2000. Overall, the model parameters calibrated from 1998 data improved the fit slightly but with higher RMSE values for the three independent years than the 1998 data set. Averaged across the 3 yr, the modified model underpredicted biomass at harvest and grain yield by 14 and 6%, respectively, with RMSE for biomass at harvest and grain yield averaging 1181 and 814 kg ha−1, respectively. The inaccuracy was related to underprediction of early vegetative growth because of the effect of site‐specific and planting date–specific differences in temperature on biomass accumulation and leaf area index. It was concluded that the modified parameters improved the accuracy of the CROPGRO‐Soybean model for the calibration year but did not significantly improve prediction for the three independent years.Keywords
Funding Information
- Iowa Soybean Promotion Board
- Illinois Soybean Checkoff Board
- Wisconsin Soybean Marketing Board
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- Soybean Agronomic Response to Management Systems in the Upper MidwestAgronomy Journal, 2003
- Developing Genetic Coefficients for Crop Simulation Models with Data from Crop Performance TrialsCrop Science, 2001
- Comparison of Two Phenology Models for Predicting Flowering and Maturity Date of SoybeanCrop Science, 1996
- Modeling the Occurrence of Reproductive Stages after Flowering for Four Soybean CultivarsAgronomy Journal, 1994
- BEANGRO: A Process‐Oriented Dry Bean Model with a Versatile User InterfaceAgronomy Journal, 1994
- Yield‐Determining Processes in Relation to Cultivar Seed Size of Common BeanCrop Science, 1994
- Soybean Flowering Date: Linear and Logistic Models Based on Temperature and PhotoperiodCrop Science, 1991
- Simulation of Carbon Assimilation and Partitioning in MaizeAgronomy Journal, 1989
- COMPARATIVE RESPONSES OF PHOTOSYNTHESIS TO GROWTH TEMPERATURE IN SOYBEAN (Glycine max [L.] Merrill) CULTIVARSCanadian Journal of Plant Science, 1988
- Response of Soybean Cultivars to Narrow Rows and Planting Rates Under Weed‐free Conditions1Agronomy Journal, 1977