This paper analytically investigates urban co-modality, i.e., using public transit systems for transporting both passengers and freight, providing strategic-level understanding of whether introducing the co-modality would benefit passengers, freight customers and operators. We model and examine the characteristics of a co-modal system, where one freight operator serves freight customers, one transit operator serves passengers, and the transit operator also serves the freight operator by carrying part of the freight. The system-wide impact of the co-modality operation is examined. The analytical conditions under which there exists a co-modality strategy that improves the consumer surpluses of transit and freight users and the two operators’ profits against the status quo without co-modality are derived. We also analytically and numerically compare the optimal operation decisions, operators' profits and users' welfare under different operation regimes (e.g., profit-driven or welfare-driven) and different games between operators (non-cooperative and cooperative games). Our results show that introducing the co-modality holds the potential to improve transit and freight service qualities, and can yield a Pareto-improving outcome, i.e., consumer surpluses of passengers and freight customers are improved and profits of transit operator and freight operator are increased. Our numerical studies further show that more freight will be transported through the co-modal service if both the freight and transit operators are profit-driven than welfare-driven, i.e., profit-driven operators tend to over-use co-modal service than welfare-driven operators.