A Comparison of Partial Order Technique with Three Methods of Multi-Criteria Analysis for Ranking of Chemical Substances
Authors:
- 10 August 2002
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in Journal of Chemical Information and Computer Sciences
- Vol. 42 (5) , 1086-1098
Abstract
An alternative to the often cumbersome and time-consuming risk assessments of chemical substances could be more reliable and advanced priority setting methods. An elaboration of the simple scoring methods is provided by Hasse Diagram Technique (HDT) and/or Multi-Criteria Analysis (MCA). The present study provides an in depth evaluation of HDT relative to three MCA techniques. The new and main methodological step in the comparison is the use of probability concepts based on mathematical tools such as linear extensions of partially ordered sets and Monte Carlo simulations. A data set consisting of 12 High Production Volume Chemicals (HPVCs) is used for illustration. It is a paradigm in this investigation to claim that the need of external input (often subjective weightings of criteria) should be minimized and that the transparency should be maximized in any multicriteria prioritisation. The study illustrates that the Hasse diagram technique (HDT) needs least external input, is most transparent and is least subjective. However, HDT has some weaknesses if there are criteria which exclude each other. Then weighting is needed. Multi-Criteria Analysis (i.e. Utility Function approach, PROMETHEE and concordance analysis) can deal with such mutual exclusions because their formalisms to quantify preferences allow participation e.g. weighting of criteria. Consequently MCA include more subjectivity and loose transparency. The recommendation which arises from this study is that the first step in decision making is to run HDT and as the second step possibly is to run one of the MCA algorithms.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- The influence on partial order ranking from input parameter uncertaintyChemosphere, 2000
- A Theoretical Concept To Rank Environmentally Significant ChemicalsJournal of Chemical Information and Computer Sciences, 1998
- A screening method for ranking and scoring chemicals by potential human health and environmental impactsEnvironmental Toxicology and Chemistry, 1997
- Quantitative structure-activity relationships and ecological risk assessment: an overview of predictive aquatic toxicology researchToxicology Letters, 1995
- A new method for site suitability analysis: The analytic hierarchy processEnvironmental Management, 1989
- Groundwater ubiquity score: A simple method for assessing pesticide leachabilityEnvironmental Toxicology and Chemistry, 1989
- Environmental Hazard Ranking of Chemicals Spilled in the Rhine River in November 1986Acta Hydrochimica et Hydrobiologica, 1989
- On ranking chemicals for environmental hazardEnvironmental Science & Technology, 1986
- How to select and how to rank projects: The Promethee methodEuropean Journal of Operational Research, 1986
- Average height in a partially ordered setDiscrete Mathematics, 1982