Outcome comparison between percutaneous cholecystostomy and cholecystectomy: a 10-year population-based analysis
Open Access
- 7 December 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Surgery
- Vol. 17 (1) , 130
Abstract
Controversy surrounding the role of percutaneous cholecystostomy (PC) is fed by the absence of large amounts of data concerning its outcomes, and many authors have maintained that there is no evidence to support a recommendation for PC rather than cholecystectomy (CCS) in elderly or critically ill patients with acute cholecystitis (AC). We conducted this study by tracking trends in the utilization and outcomes of PC and CCS using longitudinal health research data in Taiwan. Analyses were conducted on 236,742 patients, 11,184 of whom had undergone PC and 225,558 of whom had undergone CCS. Average annual percentage changes (AAPCs) from 2003 to 2012 increased significantly by 18.34% each year for PC and by 2.82% each year for CCS. The subset analyzes showed that the mortality rates were far higher in patients underwent PC than in patients underwent CCS in all subgroups, which increased from a minimum of 1.45-fold to a maximum of 34.22-fold. The gap of the mortality rates between PC group and CCS group narrowed as the patients aged and with the seriousness of the diseases increased. Most patients with PC or CCS who died in-hospital or within 30 days after discharge were 70 years of age or older, and a large number of them received a CCI score of at least 1. The AAPCs of the overall mortality rates from 2003 to 2012 decreased by 6.78% each year for PC and by 7.33% each year for CCS. PC was related to a higher rate of cholecystitis recurrence and readmission for complications, but a lower rate of in-hospital complications and routine discharge than CCS, and 36.41% of all patients treated with PC underwent subsequent CCS. Additionally, the patients with PC experienced longer hospital stays and generated higher costs than the patients with CCS. Patients who underwent PC demonstrated poorer prognoses than did patients who underwent CCS. The role of PC in the Tokyo guidelines may be overstated; it is not as safe as the Tokyo guidelines have suggested in moderate-grade cholecystitis cases, and it should be limited to only the elderly and sicker patients.Keywords
Funding Information
- Ministry of Science and Technology, Taiwan (MOST 104-2218-E-155-004 and MOST-105-2221-E-155-041-MY3)
- Research project of Xiamen overseas students (XRS201631401)
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- Changing Trends and Outcomes in the Use of Percutaneous Cholecystostomy Tubes for Acute CholecystitisAnnals of Surgery, 2013
- A nationwide examination of outcomes of percutaneous cholecystostomy compared with cholecystectomy for acute cholecystitis, 1998–2010Surgical Endoscopy, 2013
- Acute cholecystitis in high risk surgical patients: percutaneous cholecystostomy versus laparoscopic cholecystectomy (CHOCOLATE trial): Study protocol for a randomized controlled trialTrials, 2012
- Estimating average annual per cent change in trend analysisStatistics in Medicine, 2009
- Nationwide epidemiological study of severe gallstone disease in TaiwanBMC Gastroenterology, 2009
- Systematic review of cholecystostomy as a treatment option in acute cholecystitisHPB, 2009
- Diagnostic criteria and severity assessment of acute cholangitis: Tokyo GuidelinesJournal of Hepato-Biliary-Pancreatic Surgery, 2007
- PERCUTANEOUS CHOLECYSTOSTOMY IN THE MANAGEMENT OF ACUTE CHOLECYSTITISAnz Journal of Surgery, 2005
- Outcomes analysis of laparoscopic cholecystectomy in the extremely elderlySurgical Endoscopy, 2001
- Percutaneous transhepatic cholecystostomy for acute acalculous cholecystitisBritish Journal of Surgery, 1993