Comparison of methods for assessing Chlamydia trachomatis transmission intensity: a systematic review
Preprint
Abstract
Structured Topic: To assess the relationship between field-graded trachomatous inflammation—follicular (TF) and other methodologies for evaluating Chlamydia trachomatis ( Ct) transmission intensity. Clinical relevance: TF has limitations as the sole indicator of Ct transmission for trachoma programmatic decision-making. The relationships between TF and other indicators, including other clinical signs, photography, infection, and serology have yet to be synthesized. Methods: A systematic review was conducted. Five databases (MEDLINE, EMBASE, Global Health database, Scopus, and Global Index Medicus) were searched on October 19, 2022, and the e-Theses Online Service was searched on April 12, 2023. Studies from 1987 onward that reported primary data collection of field-graded TF in children and at least one other indicator were included. To compare field-graded vs. photo-graded TF, the mean difference in prevalence and 95% confidence intervals (CIs) were calculated. To compare field-graded TF against the other indicators, weighted correlation coefficients and p-values were calculated in pre-vs. post-antibiotic mass drug administration (MDA) settings. The review protocol was prospectively registered with PROSPERO (CRD42022356013). Results: A total of 35,764 studies were screened, yielding 235 included studies from 49 countries, spanning the years (of data collection) 1991–2021. For field-graded vs. photo-graded TF (n=10), the mean difference in prevalence was 0.7 percentage points, 95% CI (−15.2–16.7). The relationship between TF and other indicators was stronger pre-vs. post-MDA: TF vs infection (R 2 : 0.43, p=0.003 vs. R 2 : 0.002, p=0.788); TF vs seroprevalence (R 2 : 0.56, p2 : 0.03, p=0.353); and TF vs seroconversion rate (SCR) (R 2 : 0.52, p=0.012 vs. R 2 : 0.26, p=0.061). Post-MDA, infection and SCR were highly correlated (R 2 : 0.71, p=0.001). In studies reporting data used for programmatic decision-making, 48% of the areas warranting MDA based solely on TF had at least one other indicator categorized as indicating “low” or “medium” Ct transmission intensity. Conclusions: The correlation between TF and measures of infection and serology weakens post-initiation of MDA, which is strongly suggestive of poor performance of TF prevalence for guiding programmatic decision-making post-MDA. Measures of infection and SCR are strongly correlated with each other post-MDA. Infection and/or serology should be considered to help guide programmatic decision-making post-MDA. Target Journal: OphthalmologyKeywords
This publication has 234 references indexed in Scilit:
- Ocular Chlamydia trachomatis infection, anti-Pgp3 antibodies and conjunctival scarring in Vanuatu and Tarawa, Kiribati before antibiotic treatment for trachomaJournal of Infection, 2020
- Optimization of a rapid test for antibodies to the Chlamydia trachomatis antigen Pgp3Diagnostic Microbiology and Infectious Disease, 2019
- Surveillance Surveys for Reemergent Trachoma in Formerly Endemic Districts in Nepal From 2 to 10 Years After Mass Drug Administration CessationJAMA Ophthalmology, 2017
- PRESS Peer Review of Electronic Search Strategies: 2015 Guideline StatementJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2016
- Data Analysis2016
- Etiological characteristics of chlamydia trachoma conjunctivitis of Primary Boarding School students in the Qinghai Tibetan areaScience China Life Sciences, 2016
- Study of infectious conjunctivitis among children in rural areas of Qinghai provinceScience China Life Sciences, 2016
- Can We Stop Mass Drug Administration Prior to 3 Annual Rounds in Communities With Low Prevalence of Trachoma?JAMA Ophthalmology, 2013
- Risk of trachoma in a SAFE intervention areaInternational Ophthalmology, 2012
- Diagnosis of Chlamydia trachomatis eye infection in Tanzania by polymerase chain reaction/enzyme immunoassayThe Lancet, 1991