When choosing the traits of children is hurtful to others
- 20 October 2010
- journal article
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 37 (2) , 105-108
Abstract
Some commentators object to the use of embryonic and fetal diagnostic technologies by parents who wish to avoid disabilities in their children. In particular, they say this use is hurtful in the meaning it expresses, namely that the lives of people with disabilities are not valuable or are less valuable than the lives of others. Other commentators have tried to show that this meaning does not necessarily belong to parents' choices and is not therefore credible as a general moral objection. However, this analysis overlooks the way in which the use of these technologies can be legitimately interpreted as hurtful. Once we admit to these hurtful effects felt by people with disabilities and those who hold them dear, it becomes important to ask whether that hurt can justify limits on parents' choices. Because the use of these technologies does not hurt people with disabilities directly and because there is no requirement that people having children work to ensure the continued existence of people with disabilities, no justification for limiting parents' choices is to be found in the hurt some people experience in steps taken to avoid disabilities in children.Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- Deciding against disability: does the use of reproductive genetic technologies express disvalue for people with disabilities?Journal of Medical Ethics, 2010
- Choosing disabilities and enhancements in children: a choice too far?Reproductive BioMedicine Online, 2009
- The expressivist objection to prenatal diagnosis: can it be laid to rest?Journal of Medical Ethics, 2007
- Deaf lesbians, “designer disability,” and the future of medicineBMJ, 2002
- Procreative Beneficence: Why We Should Select the Best ChildrenBioethics, 2001
- Parental Selection of Children's Sexual OrientationArchives of Sexual Behavior, 2001
- Prenatal Diagnosis, Personal Identity, and DisabilityKennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, 2000
- Special Supplement: The Disability Rights Critique of Prenatal Genetic Testing Reflections and RecommendationsHastings Center Report, 1999
- Choosing Who Will Be Disabled: Genetic Intervention and the Morality of InclusionSocial Philosophy and Policy, 1996