Impact of the PROCESS guideline on the reporting of surgical case series: A before and after study
- 1 September 2017
- journal article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in International Journal of Surgery
- Vol. 45, 92-97
Abstract
The PROCESS guideline was developed in 2016 through expert Delphi consensus. It aimed to improve the quality of reporting of surgical case series. This study assessed the impact of the introduction of the PROCESS guideline on reporting for surgical case series submitted to three journals. 20 case series published in the International Journal of Surgery Case Reports (IJSCR), the International Journal of Surgery (IJS) or the Annals of Medicine and Surgery (AMS) in September to December 2016, prior to the introduction of the PROCESS guideline (the pre-PROCESS period), were randomly identified and scored against the PROCESS criteria. Two authors independently scored each article a total score out of 29, the 'PROCESS score' (expressed as a percentage). Scores for the two researchers were compared and consensus was reached to achieve a final score set. The process was repeated for the January 2017 to April 2017 issues of the three journals, post PROCESS implementation (the post-PROCESS period). The mean PROCESS score was 80% (range 66-90%) for the pre-PROCESS period and 84% (range 72-95%) for the post-PROCESS period, a 4% relative increase [STATS]. The Cohen's Kappa score between researchers was 0.907 implying very substantial agreement. Implementation of the PROCESS guideline resulted in a 5% improvement in the reporting quality of surgical case series published in three journals. Further research is needed to identify and successfully navigate existing barriers to greater compliance. Authors, reviewers and editors should adhere to the guidelines to boost reporting quality. Journals should develop their policies and guide for authors to incorporate the guideline and mandate compliance.Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- Support for reporting guidelines in surgical journals needs improvement: A systematic reviewInternational Journal of Surgery, 2017
- Preferred reporting of case series in surgery; the PROCESS guidelinesInternational Journal of Surgery, 2016
- Systematic review of the methodological and reporting quality of case series in surgeryBritish Journal of Surgery, 2016
- Levels of evidence in plastic surgery—bibliometric trends and comparison with five other surgical specialtiesEuropean Journal of Plastic Surgery, 2016
- Impact of the mandatory implementation of reporting guidelines on reporting quality in a surgical journal: A before and after studyInternational Journal of Surgery, 2016
- Use of autologous fat grafting for breast reconstruction: A systematic review with meta-analysis of oncological outcomesJournal of Plastic, Reconstructive & Aesthetic Surgery, 2015
- Propranolol for Severe Hemangiomas of InfancyNew England Journal of Medicine, 2008
- Vacuum-Assisted Closure: A New Method for Wound Control and TreatmentAnnals of Plastic Surgery, 1997
- Hemangiomas and Vascular Malformations in Infants and ChildrenPlastic and Reconstructive Surgery, 1982