The paradox of victory: social movement fields, adverse outcomes, and social movement success
Open Access
- 2 October 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Theory and Society
- Vol. 51 (1) , 31-60
Abstract
Recent work on social movement fields has expanded our view of the dynamics of social movements; it should also expand our thinking about social movement success. Such a broader view reveals a paradox: social movements often snatch defeat from the jaws of victory by narrowly targeting authorities with their actions instead of targeting the broader social movement field. Negative impacts from the wider social movement field can then reverse or overshadow initial victories. We distinguish between a social movement’s victory over the immediate target, and more lasting success that arises from shifting alignments in the broader social movement field. To test the predictive value of the distinction, we compare two very similar student-led social movements, both of which targeted university policies regarding sensitivity to race issues and changes in university personnel. One built a broad coalition of support that extended across its social movement field and was thereby able to institute durable change. The other did not, and despite its clear initial success, this protest movement produced consequences mainly adverse to its preferred outcomes. We demonstrate how pervasive this paradox is with examples from other U.S. protest outcomes and studies of revolutions. The paradox is resolved by focusing on changes in the entire social movement field. We thus argue that achieving, and understanding, lasting social movement success requires attention to the entire social movement field.Keywords
This publication has 50 references indexed in Scilit:
- Putting Values and Institutions Back into the Theory of Strategic Action FieldsSociological Theory, 2012
- The Political Consequences of Social MovementsAnnual Review of Sociology, 2010
- Why Civil Resistance Works: The Strategic Logic of Nonviolent ConflictInternational Security, 2008
- Social Movements and Public Policy When Movements Matter: The Townsend Plan and the Rise of Social Security by Edwin Amenta Princeton University Press, 2006, 322 PagesContexts, 2007
- Corn, Klansmen, and Coolidge: Structure and Framing in Social MovementsSocial Forces, 2004
- How Social Movements MatterContexts, 2003
- The Impact of Political Parties, Interest Groups, and Social Movement Organizations on Public Policy: Some Recent Evidence and Theoretical ConcernsSocial Forces, 2002
- Power in Movement: Social Movements and Contentious PoliticsContemporary Sociology: A Journal of Reviews, 1999
- The Iron Cage Revisited: Institutional Isomorphism and Collective Rationality in Organizational FieldsAmerican Sociological Review, 1983
- Poor People's Movements: Why They Succeed, How they FailThe American Historical Review, 1978