Outlier surgeons—those surgeons who violate universally accepted standards of care—are few and far between, but they are out there. You may have crossed paths with them in the course of patient care. They may work at your hospital, or you may have read about them in your local paper, or even encountered them in legal proceedings. But if you have been in practice long enough, chances are you may know who some of these outliers are. The question is, what can we do about them? What are our responsibilities to police our own? I remember a dinner I had with several other surgeons in the community early in my practice. We discussed another one of our surgical colleagues in the community who, by reputation, employed loose indications for surgery. This surgeon’s practice patterns, from our perspective, seemed to be financially driven. In one egregious example, the surgeon had allegedly intentionally displaced a nondisplaced fracture to justify going to the operating r ...