The Conceptual Tragedy in Studying Defense Mechanisms
- 18 January 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Integrative Psychological and Behavioral Science
- Vol. 54 (2) , 354-369
Abstract
The concept of defense mechanism is interwoven with psychoanalytic theories of anxiety and psychic conflict. From its first formulation in 1894, its usefulness resides in the degree to which it helps to explain otherwise mysterious phenomena. Statistical approaches to the study of defense mechanisms, which have significantly increased in popularity in the past three decades, test isolated assumptions without reflection on how these are integrated into psychoanalytic theory, nor on what should be regarded as psychoanalytic data. Consequently, their results and their models have not provided useful insights into psychoanalytic theory. This paper aims to show how these issues in statistical approaches largely stem from disregarding discussions on the ontological status of defense mechanisms and the epistemological consequences linked to them. Studying defense mechanisms as they are manifested in external lifestyles, clouds the distinction between constructs (explanatory terms) and phenomena (empirical referents), which is furthermore necessary for a theoretical model to have explanatory value. Concrete examples are given regarding problems in statistical conceptualizations of defense mechanisms as well as the cursory explanations these tend to describe. Implications for future research are discussed.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Freudian Defense Mechanisms and Empirical Findings in Modern Social Psychology: Reaction Formation, Projection, Displacement, Undoing, Isolation, Sublimation, and DenialJournal of Personality, 1998
- A Critical Appraisal of Self‐Report Defense Mechanism MeasuresJournal of Personality, 1998
- Coping and Defense Mechanisms: What's the Difference?Journal of Personality, 1998
- Ego mechanisms of defense and personality psychopathology.Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 1994
- Anger and the Use of Defense Mechanisms in College StudentsJournal of Personality, 1991
- Recent Contributions to the Theory of Defense Mechanisms: A Comparative ViewJournal of the American Psychoanalytic Association, 1989
- The Development of Defense MechanismsJournal of Personality, 1987
- Basic Principles And Techniques In Short-Term Dynamic Psychotherapy.Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association, 1983
- A Note On Projective IdentificationJournal of the American Psychoanalytic Association, 1980
- Development and Metapsychology of the Defense Organization of the EgoJournal of the American Psychoanalytic Association, 1967