Learning from Inconsistent Performance Feedback
- 12 December 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Organization Science
Abstract
Organizations and the decision makers within them are increasingly subject to inconsistent performance feedback—feedback that contains elements that are incompatible with each other—which can lead to multiple interpretations of performance feedback. When this occurs, decision makers often recode inconsistent performance feedback as successful and continue with their current strategies, which allows them to avoid any self-threat from negative elements of performance feedback but implies that they do not learn from inconsistent performance feedback because they do not change. In contrast, we explore whether decision makers can learn from inconsistent performance feedback. Leveraging over 10 years of complete behavioral records in an online community and a laboratory experiment, we study how decision makers respond to inconsistent performance feedback stemming from multiple evaluators who do not agree on performance quality. Consistent with prior work, we find that decision makers change their strategies less after inconsistent performance feedback. Departing from prior work, we show a corresponding increase in clarification efforts aimed at better understanding which performance strategies work well. Importantly, clarification efforts mediate improved future performance. Our results suggest that inconsistent performance feedback can trigger deeper learning and enhanced performance, contributing to performance feedback theory and research on the microfoundations of organizational learning. Funding: The authors thank the University of São Paulo, Johns Hopkins University, and SKEMA Business School for institutional and financial support. Supplemental Material: The online appendix is available at https://doi.org/10.1287/orsc.2022.16833 .Keywords
This publication has 92 references indexed in Scilit:
- Difference-in-differences with variation in treatment timingJournal of Econometrics, 2021
- Difference-in-Differences with multiple time periodsJournal of Econometrics, 2021
- Searching for knowledge in response to proximate and remote problem sources: Evidence from the U.S. renewable electricity industryStrategic Management Journal, 2020
- Biased interpretation of performance feedback: The role of CEO overconfidenceStrategic Management Journal, 2020
- An accountability account: A review and synthesis of the theoretical and empirical research on felt accountabilityJournal of Organizational Behavior, 2015
- The fog of feedback: Ambiguity and firm responses to multiple aspiration levelsStrategic Management Journal, 2014
- Aspirations, innovation, and corporate venture capital: A behavioral perspectiveStrategic Entrepreneurship Journal, 2012
- The fixed effects negative binomial model revisitedEconomics Letters, 2008
- Multimarket contact and sales growth: evidence from insuranceStrategic Management Journal, 2007
- The myopia of learningStrategic Management Journal, 1993