Abstract
Poverty and health: powerful connection Although targeting “the poor” is clearly important, inequalities and inequities in health are not only about the plight of the most deprived in each society. In many low income countries, over half the population may be living in poverty and those who are not will still be living in circumstances that contribute to the poor health of the country as a whole. Even in high income countries, where there is little absolute poverty, there are fine and graduated inequalities in health status that span the full socioeconomic spectrum. For example, in a study of 300 000 men in the United States, mortality declined progressively across 12 categories of household income from less than $7500 (£5000) to more than $32 499.5 Although not all governments perceive inequalities in wealth and health to be something the public sector can or should address, all governments are interested in improving economic growth. Under the leadership of Gro Harlem Bruntland, the World Health Organization now argues forcibly that health is key to reducing poverty and to development. If improving health can have a positive effect on economic growth, then health should become a central priority of every government: “Because ill-health traps people in poverty, sustained investment in the health of the poor could provide a policy lever for alleviating persistent poverty.”6 Recent advances There is currently a wave of international and national interest in tackling health inequalities and poverty Per capita expenditure on health does not determine life expectancy in a country Intelligent and equitable investment in social policy can improve health, even in poor countries with low economic growth Comparisons of inequalities in health internationally are complicated by debates over measurement and adequacy of data The aetiological mechanisms driving socioeconomic differences in health depend on disease and context Effective action depends on a better understanding of the full scope of current scientific, conceptual, and policy debates This emphasis on the potential causal link running from ill health to poverty, rather than vice versa, is contentious.7 The evidence base to support the wealth creating potential of improved health is far less substantial than the evidence relating poor health to poverty. Nevertheless, the causal links between poverty and health clearly must run in both directions to some degree and can generate a vicious or virtuous cycle. This complexity needs to be accounted for in conceptual models linking health with wealth or poverty and needs to inform strategies aimed at improving health and reducing poverty and inequalities in wealth. However, it is important not to lose sight of the intrinsic value of alleviating poverty and ill health. Poverty and ill health impair the capability of individuals to realise their own goals—and redressing that damage cannot be reduced to the economics of wealth creation.8 This leads to the question of the best economic strategy for improving health and welfare. Positions are divided. One argument is that priority should be given to promoting economic growth so as to accumulate sufficient wealth to then (and only then) invest adequately in programmes to tackle ill health and poverty. A second argument advocates a “support led” strategy. Even in countries where economic growth is minimal, intelligent and equitable investment in social policies can improve health and welfare.9 This view is consistent with the strikingly high life expectancy in countries such as China, Sri Lanka, and Costa Rica, where per capita wealth and expenditure on health are low by international standards (fig). View larger version: In this window In a new window Life expectancy at birth in 1999 by per capita total health expenditure in 1997 in 70 countries for which the world health report indicated that data on life expectancy and expenditure were reliable10 The figure provides a powerful summary of global inequalities in life expectancy and inequities in health expenditure. It also suggests that, between countries, per capita health expenditure bears little relation to life expectancy. The world is divided in two. Just over half the countries shown have an annual per capita expenditure of less than $500, one seventh of that of the United States. In this group of low spending countries there is huge variation in life expectancy. Conversely, in medium and high expenditure countries, there is huge variation in per capita expenditure, which shows almost no relation to life expectancy. Much of the international variation in mortality has to be accounted for by factors determining differences in occurrence of disease. This will include the effects of investment in the social sector, particularly in education, as well as in public health over the long term.