Smoothness metrics for reaching performance after stroke. Part 1: which one to choose?
Authors:
Open Access
- 26 October 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of NeuroEngineering and Rehabilitation
- Vol. 18 (1) , 1-16
Abstract
Background: Smoothness is commonly used for measuring movement quality of the upper paretic limb during reaching tasks after stroke. Many different smoothness metrics have been used in stroke research, but a ‘valid’ metric has not been identified. A systematic review and subsequent rigorous analysis of smoothness metrics used in stroke research, in terms of their mathematical definitions and response to simulated perturbations, is needed to conclude whether they are valid for measuring smoothness. Our objective was to provide a recommendation for metrics that reflect smoothness after stroke based on: (1) a systematic review of smoothness metrics for reaching used in stroke research, (2) the mathematical description of the metrics, and (3) the response of metrics to simulated changes associated with smoothness deficits in the reaching profile.Methods: The systematic review was performed by screening electronic databases using combined keyword groupsStroke,ReachingandSmoothness. Subsequently, each metric identified was assessed with mathematical criteria regarding smoothness: (a) being dimensionless, (b) being reproducible, (c) being based on rate of change of position, and (d) not being a linear transform of other smoothness metrics. The resulting metrics were tested for their response to simulated changes in reaching using models of velocity profiles with varying reaching distances and durations, harmonic disturbances, noise, and sub-movements. Two reaching tasks were simulated; reach-to-point and reach-to-grasp. The metrics that responded as expected in all simulation analyses were considered to be valid.Results: The systematic review identified 32 different smoothness metrics, 17 of which were excluded based on mathematical criteria, and 13 more as they did not respond as expected in all simulation analyses. Eventually, we found that, for reach-to-point and reach-to-grasp movements, onlySpectral Arc Length(SPARC) was found to be a valid metric.Conclusions: Based on this systematic review and simulation analyses, we recommend the use of SPARC as a valid smoothness metric in both reach-to-point and reach-to-grasp tasks of the upper limb after stroke. However, further research is needed to understand the time course of smoothness measured with SPARC for the upper limb early post stroke, preferably in longitudinal studies.Keywords
Funding Information
- FP7 Ideas: European Research Council (291339)
- Stichting voor de Technische Wetenschappen (NeuroCIMT project 14905)
This publication has 79 references indexed in Scilit:
- An Updated Definition of Stroke for the 21st CenturyStroke, 2013
- Monitoring motor capacity changes of children during rehabilitation using body-worn sensorsJournal of NeuroEngineering and Rehabilitation, 2013
- The Neurorehabilitation Training Toolkit (NTT): A Novel Worldwide Accessible Motor Training Approach for At-Home Rehabilitation after StrokeStroke Research and Treatment, 2012
- Stroke rehabilitationThe Lancet, 2011
- Quantifying the quality of hand movement in stroke patients through three-dimensional curvatureJournal of NeuroEngineering and Rehabilitation, 2011
- A proof of concept study for the integration of robot therapy with physiotherapy in the treatment of stroke patientsClinical Rehabilitation, 2009
- Quantitative evaluation of functional limitation of upper limb movements in subjects affected by ataxiaEuropean Journal of Neurology, 2009
- Sensitivity of Smoothness Measures to Movement Duration, Amplitude, and ArrestsJournal of Motor Behavior, 2009
- Recovery of Grasp versus Reach in People with Hemiparesis PoststrokeNeurorehabilitation and Neural Repair, 2006
- Role of intrinsic muscle properties in producing smooth movementsIEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering, 1997