Abstract
Understanding evacuation behavior is essential for effective emergency planning, yet studies based on hypothetical scenarios might not accurately represent how people respond during actual events. This study compares intended and actual tsunami evacuation behavior using two surveys conducted in the same coastal communities. The pre-event survey in 2021 examined responses to a hypothetical tsunami scenario, while a post-event survey examined responses following the December 2024 Northern California earthquake and tsunami warning. Because a small number of households completed both questionnaires, sample comparability was assessed using statistical tests and graphical homogeneity analysis. Differences between the two surveys were examined across four dimensions of protective behavior: risk awareness, risk perception, evacuation decision-making, and evacuation behavior. The results reveal a mixed pattern of similarities and differences between intended and actual responses. Compared with respondents in the hypothetical survey, those who experienced the actual tsunami warning perceived lower levels of situational risk. Consequently, they were less likely to evacuate (36.6% vs. 80.5%). Conversely, evacuation preparation occurred more rapidly during the actual event than respondents had expected in the hypothetical scenario, whereas transportation mode choices and travel times were broadly consistent between the two surveys. These findings demonstrate that some aspects of hypothetical surveys may not reliably predict actual protective behavior, highlighting the critical need for further research to identify which behavioral intentions are most likely to diverge from actual behavior and the factors contributing to those inconsistencies. At the same time, the observed similarities suggest that hypothetical surveys remain informative for certain dimensions of evacuation behavior. Overall, these findings provide important insights for improving tsunami evacuation modeling, emergency planning, risk communication, and community resilience to near-field tsunami hazards.