Abstract
Tropical soils store large amounts of soil organic carbon (SOC), but the mechanisms governing its persistence vary among mineralogical, hydrological, biological, and geomorphic settings. This structured critical review examines when particular processes become limiting for SOC persistence rather than treating soil-forming factors as universal controls. An auditable corpus of 78 unique records was screened using eligibility and evidence-characterization criteria, with 70 records retained for qualitative synthesis. Evidence was evaluated according to study design, environmental context, mechanism, spatial and temporal scale, and inferential directness. Five recurring limiting regimes emerged: carbon-input limitation, microbial-transformation limitation, reactive-mineral-capacity limitation, accessibility limitation associated with aggregation or oxygen restriction, and residence-time limitation associated with vertical or lateral redistribution. Reactive Fe and Al phases can promote mineral-associated organic matter (MAOM) formation when reactive surfaces are accessible and carbon precursors reach them, whereas additional inputs may produce limited MAOM gains when accessible mineral capacity is occupied. Microbial transformation and aggregation act as coupled pathways controlling carbon supply and accessibility, but their effects remain sensitive to nutrient status and disturbance. Redox oscillation, erosion, and hydrological redistribution can alter or override local mineral protection. These boundary conditions help explain contrasting findings across Ferralsols, Acrisols, Andisols, Podzols, savannas, and hydromorphic systems. We propose an operational framework linking mechanisms to measurable indicators, spatial and temporal scales, disturbance tests, and evidence strength, and translate it into a testable Colombian research agenda based on full profiles, pedoclimatic stratification, functional carbon fractions, mineralogy, redox dynamics, and landscape mass balance.