Examining Editor-Author Ethics: Real-World Scenarios from Interviews with Three Journal Editors
- 11 June 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Technical Writing and Communication
- Vol. 39 (3) , 285-303
Abstract
Those who submit manuscripts to academic journals may benefit from a better understanding of how editors weigh ethics in their interactions with authors. In an attempt to ascertain and to understand editors' ethics, we interviewed 3 current academic journal editors of technical and/or business communication journals. We asked them about the ethical dilemmas they encountered while working with authors, whether the editors formally or informally followed a “code of ethics,” and if they felt obligated to maintain any ethical codes in particular. In this article, we discuss the ethical dimensions of editorial practices using specific ethical scenarios provided by these three editors. We then analyze these scenarios using traditional ethical models in our field but also in terms of a less-known but powerful model of ethical analysis originally proposed by the philosopher C. S. Peirce. We argue that Peirce's “community of inquiry” ethics model best describes these journal editors' ethics when working with authors.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Perceptions of Memo Quality: A Case Study of Engineering Practitioners, Professors, and StudentsJournal of Technical Writing and Communication, 2005
- Act well thy part: performing technical writer and engineerIEEE Transactions on Professional Communication, 2004
- On Editing and Contributing to a Field: The Everyday Work of EditorsPedagogy, 2004
- What is thought?IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication, 2002
- The grammar instinctIEEE Transactions on Professional Communication, 2002
- What is explanation?IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication, 2001
- Ethics for editors: an analytical decision-making processIEEE Transactions on Professional Communication, 1998
- Ethics and technical communication: a case for foundational approachesIEEE Transactions on Professional Communication, 1997
- Stories of Three EditorsJournal of Business and Technical Communication, 1995
- Ethos: character and ethics in technical writingIEEE Transactions on Professional Communication, 1995