Abstract
Background: Peritoneal vaginoplasty is increasingly being adopted within feminizing genital gender-affirming surgery. However, the way and extent to which peritoneum is used for vaginal lining varies considerably, and the term “peritoneal vaginoplasty” appears to encompass several technically distinct procedures. Aim: To assess technical variation and surgical indications in gender-affirming peritoneal vaginoplasty, and evaluate evidence maturity through the lens of the Idea, Development, Exploration, Assessment and Long-term study (IDEAL) framework. Methods: A systematic search identified studies reporting use of peritoneum in gender-affirming vaginoplasty. Data on surgical characteristics and indications were extracted as primary outcomes and data on evidence maturity as secondary outcomes. Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines were followed, and risk of bias was assessed using Joanna Briggs Institute checklists. Outcomes: Primary outcomes were technical characteristics, including flap number, configuration, vascularization, extent of vaginal lining, surgical indication, postoperative management, and reported outcomes. Secondary outcomes included study design, rationale for innovation, prospective registration, informed consent, outcome selection, outcome measures, and IDEAL stage. Results: Of 1425 screened records, 23 full-text and five video articles were included, representing 14 centers. Techniques were categorized into four groups based on peritoneal flap number, configuration, and vascularization. Substantial heterogeneity was observed in technical characteristics, surgical indications, and postoperative management. Techniques were largely center-specific, and indications ranged from routine use in primary vaginoplasty to genital skin deficiency, patient preference, and secondary reconstruction. No included publication reported prospective registration or referred to a published protocol. Informed consent was reported in six studies. Rationale for innovation, outcome selection, and technical choices was absent or limited. Safety was the predominant outcome, with 22 of 23 full-text studies reporting complications, whereas only three included survey-based patient-reported outcomes. Two studies were most consistent with IDEAL stage 2a. The remaining studies could not be staged. Clinical implications: Peritoneal vaginoplasty should not be regarded as a single intervention. Technique- and indication-specific evaluation is needed to identify which patients may benefit most from each approach and in whom specific techniques may be inappropriate or contraindicated. Strengths and limitations: Strengths include the comprehensive technical overview and structured evaluation using IDEAL. Limitations include incomplete reporting, probable participant overlap, and heterogeneity precluding pooled outcome synthesis. Conclusion: Peritoneal vaginoplasty comprises a heterogeneous group of techniques rather than a standardized procedure. Technical variation, differing indications, and heterogeneous outcome reporting preclude clinically meaningful comparison of safety and effectiveness. Prospective, technique- and indication-specific studies are required to determine the clinical role of individual techniques.

This publication has 53 references indexed in Scilit: