Editorial: Quantum and quantum-like effects across neuroscience
Open Access
- 8 April 2026
- journal article
- editorial
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Human Neuroscience
- Vol. 20, 1838245
Abstract
Editorial: Quantum and quantum-like effects across neuroscience, volume 1.For about thirty years now a growing literature has applied quantum probability theory to successfully describe a wide range of statistical question-answering phenomena in psychology that appear irrational from a classical perspective (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11).In the present volume, (12) presents a systematic motivation for applying a quantum-like (QL) statistical framework to model human behavior "beyond individual cognition," at the level of networks of reasoning individuals and social institutions. That study also provides a generic task-independent decomposition of QL effects into several clearly delineated phenomena whose experimental signatures can be compared across domains such as psychology, political science, sociology, and neuroscience. This paper can also function as a concise introduction to QL modelling of cognition, with concrete examples showing how human choice behaviors treated as errors or ad hoc special cases under a classical formalism, can be understood as systematic context-sensitivity under a QL model.(13) in the present volume uses a comparable approach to interpret public data pertaining to the effectiveness of teams, arguing that the QL description reveals performance gains from allowing "interdependence" among team members, that are obscured under a purely classical model. Interdependence here can be understood as an aspect of the context-sensitivity inherent in QL models.The behavioral results of the QL cognition program are striking and robust enough (7, 8, 9) that researchers have begun to consider potential (classical) neural implementations for generating QL cognition (14). Testing neural models for generating QL cognition will require neural measures of context-sensitivity, which is the focus of the study (15) in the present volume. That paper formulates a model of QL decision-making in terms of oscillatory states of neural networks comparable to those modeled by ( 14). The authors derive rigorous measures of "mental entanglement" expressing the statistical inseparability-i.e., interdependence-of neural variables that represent cognitive variables, and discuss how these measures could be extracted from EEG or MEG data. Excitingly, applying these measures to directly test for cognitive entanglement in EEG/MEG data during task performance "remains an open direction for future research." Does mental entanglement or "true contextuality" (9, 16) imply a genuinely quantum physical implementation in the brain? Not necessarily. A number of authors have argued that some quantum-like statistical phenomena, such as incompatible observables and interference, can emerge in complex classical systems when information is coarse-grained or otherwise inaccessible (17,18,19,20). However, we are not aware of a realistic classical neural model exhibiting true contextuality as defined in (9, 16).The idea that quantum physics might be relevant to understanding how the brain generates conscious cognition has been considered laughable since it was proposed by Nobel Laureate Roger Penrose and others (21,22) in the 1990s. (21,22) in the 1990s. The main objection was that the brain is too wet and warm to sustain functional quantum effects. This objection (23) was never conclusive (24), but in recent years evidence has accumulated from multiple sources to support the physical plausibility of the quantum consciousness hypothesis, particularly with respect to microtubules (MTs), the cytoskeletal proteins hypothesized by Penrose and Hameroff (21,22) to support consciousness. These include experimental reports from independent labs, suggesting quantum physical effects in MTs at room temperature, in vitro (25) and in living neurons (26,27,28). Familiar local field potential oscillations have been shown to be driven by MT resonances in the honeybee brain (29). Other work implicates MTs (30,31,32,33,34,35) and quantum spin (36,37) in anesthetic mechanisms, and non-classical MRI signals appear to support quantum consciousness in living humans (38,39). A quantum substrate of consciousness has also been argued to solve otherwise intractable conceptual problems such as the phenomenal binding problem and the problem of accounting for the evolution of adaptive conscious states (40). From the cognitive perspective, it has been pointed out that objective quantum wavefunction collapse dynamics on MTs provide a natural implementation (41, 42) of the empirically well-supported active inference model of cognition (43).Quantifying the contribution of classical and quantum mechanisms to brain function is a major challenge for neuroscience going forward, demanding rigorous quantitative frameworks for interpreting the various kinds of relevant data. Two papers in the present volume (44,45) address this challenge by proposing complementary frameworks for quantitatively describing classical structure, decoherence, and quantum effects in a physical brain.(45) in this volume describes the Method of Coherent Structures, which formulates how larger-scale structures provide a "classical envelope" for smaller-scale quantum processes, and allows for the incorporation of energy dissipation and pumping terms characterizing the far-from-thermodynamicequilibrium living state. Interestingly, a cubic nonlinearity arises naturally in this kind of model, which may provide support for little-known quantum model of visual smooth pursuit (eye-tracking)(46) that depends on a cubic nonlinearity in its quantum evolution equation, and outperforms classical models.(44) in the present volume advocates for the Quantum-Classical formalism, which also allows for the incorporation of nonequilibrium phenomena. Under this approach, the system under study is decomposed into classical and quantum subsystems. In contrast to (45), (44) focuses on using the formalism to quantitatively distinguish objective wavefunction collapse predicted under the Penrose and...Keywords
This publication has 46 references indexed in Scilit:
- Conscious active inference II: Quantum orchestrated objective reduction among intraneuronal microtubules naturally accounts for discrete perceptual cyclesComputational and Structural Biotechnology Journal, 2025
- Conscious active inference I: A quantum model naturally implements the path integral needed for real-time planning and controlComputational and Structural Biotechnology Journal, 2025
- Contextuality and context-sensitivity in probabilistic models of cognitionCognitive Psychology, 2022
- Quantum cognition: The possibility of processing with nuclear spins in the brainAnnals of Physics, 2015
- Taxane modulation of anesthetic sensitivity in surgery for nonmetastatic breast cancerJournal of Clinical Anesthesia, 2015
- Complementarity in Classical Dynamical SystemsFoundations of Physics, 2006
- A Recurrent Quantum Neural Network Model to Describe Eye Tracking of Moving TargetsFoundations of Physics Letters, 2005
- Quantum Zeno features of bistable perceptionBiological Cybernetics, 2004
- Orchestrated reduction of quantum coherence in brain microtubules: A model for consciousnessMathematics and Computers in Simulation, 1996
- Applications of quantum statistics in psychological studies of decision processesFoundations of Science, 1995