Are Peer Ratings of Student Debates Valid?

Author:

Abstract
Although many instructors use debates in various courses, little information is available regarding debate grading. This article reports an evaluation of student participation in grading debates. In most respects, student and instructor ratings correlated highly. In addition, students reported that they liked debates, that debates helped them to learn, and that evaluating other students was valuable experience. These data support the use of peer ratings in grading classroom debates.