From distance to detachment: knowledge and self-knowledge in Elias's theory of involvement and detachment
Author:
- Richard KilminsterRKRichard Kilminster
- 18 March 2004
- book chapter
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP)
- p. 25-41
Abstract
‘Detachment’ and ‘involvement’ belong to the not very large group of specialized concepts referring to the whole human person. (Norbert Elias 1987: xxxii) Introduction: after Weber Max Weber famously declared that the vocation of sociology requires that sociologists should suspend certain values in the pursuit of the ideal of ‘value-freedom’. It is obvious reading Elias's first systematic statement of his theory of involvement and detachment (Elias 1956) with Weber in mind, that on the subject of science and values, although he departs from Weber in significant ways he, too, must have been stimulated by Weber's observations. In common with many other social scientists outside Marxist circles in Weimar Germany, early in his career Elias probably acquiesced in the all-pervasive Weberian position on value-freedom (or some version of it) as a set of working principles for social-scientific work. Indeed, it was partly this broad orientation which set the sociology department of Mannheim and Elias in Frankfurt apart from the subsequently more famous ‘Frankfurt School’ of Adorno and Horkheimer with whom they shared a building (Shils 1970; Bogner 1987; Mennell 1998: 15). In a Marxian manner the latter group emphatically rejected value-freedom in any form because they saw it as part of a positivistic ideology in social science that excluded partisanship on behalf of the underprivileged (Kilminster 1979: 195–201). I think it is possible to breathe further life into this venerable subject of value-freedom through understanding how Elias took the Weberian model as a point of departure.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- How Strange to Ourselves are Our Feelings of Superiority and Inferiority?Theory, Culture & Society, 1998
- From Philosophy to Sociology: Elias and the Neo-Kantians (A Response to Benjo Maso)Theory, Culture & Society, 1995
- Norbert Elias and Karl Mannheim: Closeness and DistanceTheory, Culture & Society, 1993
- Developments in the Behavioural Codes between the Sexes: The Formalization of Informalization in the Netherlands, 1930-85Theory, Culture & Society, 1987
- Norbert Elias in Leicester: Some RecollectionsTheory, Culture & Society, 1987
- Elias and the Frankfurt SchoolTheory, Culture & Society, 1987
- The Retreat of Sociologists into the PresentTheory, Culture & Society, 1987
- Formalization and Informalization: Changing Tension Balances in Civilizing ProcessesTheory, Culture & Society, 1986
- Problems of Involvement and DetachmentThe British Journal of Sociology, 1956
- ‘PSYCHICAL DISTANCE’ AS A FACTOR IN ART AND AN AESTHETIC PRINCIPLEBritish Journal of Psychology, 1904-1920, 1912