Is Data from Community Mortality Data Mechanisms and Civil Registration and Vital Statistics Systems Compatible and Co-Usable? Evidence from a pilot Study in Nigeria
Preprint
- 15 June 2023
- preprint
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Abstract
Background: Community mortality data mechanisms (CMDMs) -including verbal autopsy programmes and mortality surveillance systems-are taken as pragmatic solutions to the mortality data incapacity of CRVS systems in Low and Middle Income Countries (LMICs). This paper addresses issues related to the compatibility and co-usability of CMDM and CRVS systems data instruments and data. It demonstrates a methodology for the development of a CRVS system compatible community mortality checklist (CMC) instrument applicable to a routine community mortality surveillance system (RCMS). It compares mortality data from the Nigerian CRVS system and a pilot implementation of RCMS using the CMC. Methods: Development of the CMC was demonstrated with the Nigerian death registration data instrument. RCMS and CRVS generated data on 180 deaths were compared in nine mortality data fields or elements of registered mortality events (ERMEs): age and sex of deceased, timeliness of registration (TOR), place -facility- of death (POD), locality of death, place of registration, death certification, and causes of death (COD). Results: Differences between RCMS and CRVS mortality data were insignificant in some ERMEs like age, sex and POD of deceased but significant in others like TOR, COD and locality of death. CRVS data were slightly less male biased and more concentrated at older age groups while RCMS data were more evenly spread across age groups. Conclusion: Data from the two sources are largely compatible. CMC based RCMS can significantly expand coverage of CRVS mortality data in LMICs and help adjust its sex and age bias.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- Estimating causes of out-of-hospital deaths in China: application of SmartVA methodsPopulation Health Metrics, 2021
- Maternal mortality in six low and lower-middle income countries from 2010 to 2018: risk factors and trendsReproductive Health, 2020
- Death registration in Nigeria: a systematic literature review of its performance and challengesGlobal Health Action, 2020
- Implementing and scaling verbal autopsies: into the unknownBMC Medicine, 2020
- Automated versus physician assignment of cause of death for verbal autopsies: randomized trial of 9374 deaths in 117 villages in IndiaBMC Medicine, 2019
- Comparing tariff and medical assistant assigned causes of death from verbal autopsy interviews in Matlab, Bangladesh: implications for a health and demographic surveillance systemPopulation Health Metrics, 2018
- Integrating community-based verbal autopsy into civil registration and vital statistics (CRVS): system-level considerationsGlobal Health Action, 2017
- The Nigerian Civil Registration and Vital Statistics System: Contexts, Institutions, OperationSocial Indicators Research, 2016
- A shortened verbal autopsy instrument for use in routine mortality surveillance systemsBMC Medicine, 2015
- How much do the physician review and InterVA model agree in determining causes of death? a comparative analysis of deaths in rural EthiopiaBMC Public Health, 2015