A Comparison of Manual and Quantitative Elbow Strength Testing
Authors:
- Keith A. BengtsonKBKeith A. Bengtson
- Allen T. BishopABAllen T. Bishop
- Alexander Y. ShinASAlexander Y. Shin
- Robert J. SpinnerRSRobert J. Spinner
- Jeffrey R. BasfordJBJeffrey R. Basford
- Kenton R. KaufmanKKKenton R. Kaufman
- 1 October 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in American Journal of Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation
- Vol. 91 (10) , 856-862
Abstract
The aim of this study was to compare the clinical ratings of elbow strength obtained by skilled clinicians with objective strength measurement obtained through quantitative testing. A retrospective comparison of subject clinical records with quantitative strength testing results in a motion analysis laboratory was conducted. A total of 110 individuals between the ages of 8 and 65 yrs with traumatic brachial plexus injuries were identified. Patients underwent manual muscle strength testing as assessed on the 5-point British Medical Research Council Scale (5/5, normal; 0/5, absent) and quantitative elbow flexion and extension strength measurements. A total of 92 subjects had elbow flexion testing. Half of the subjects clinically assessed as having normal (5/5) elbow flexion strength on manual muscle testing exhibited less than 42% of their age-expected strength on quantitative testing. Eighty-four subjects had elbow extension strength testing. Similarly, half of those displaying normal elbow extension strength on manual muscle testing were found to have less than 62% of their age-expected values on quantitative testing. Significant differences between manual muscle testing and quantitative findings were not detected for the lesser (0-4) strength grades. Manual muscle testing, even when performed by experienced clinicians, may be more misleading than expected for subjects graded as having normal (5/5) strength. Manual muscle testing estimates for the lesser strength grades (1-4/5) seem reasonably accurate.Keywords
This publication has 6 references indexed in Scilit:
- Use of the Medical Research Council Muscle Strength Grading System in the Upper ExtremityThe Journal of Hand Surgery, 2007
- Critical Reappraisal of Medical Research Council Muscle Testing for Elbow FlexionThe Journal of Hand Surgery, 2007
- A Broad Range of Forces is Encompassed by the Maximum Manual Muscle Test Grade of FivePerceptual and Motor Skills, 2000
- Subjectivity of Forces Associated with Manual-Muscle Test Grades of 3+, 4-, and 4Perceptual and Motor Skills, 1998
- Grade 4 in manual muscle testing: the problem with submaximal strength assessmentClinical Rehabilitation, 1997
- Multiple Comparisons Using Rank SumsTechnometrics, 1964