Comparison of detection and miss rates of narrow band imaging, flexible spectral imaging chromoendoscopy and white light at screening colonoscopy: a randomised controlled back-to-back study
Authors:
Abstract
Objective Virtual chromoendoscopy (CE) is expected to enhance adenoma yield and reduce variation in performance between colonoscopists. This study aimed to compare the efficacy of narrow band imaging (NBI), flexible spectral imaging CE (FICE) and white light (WL) colonoscopy and their impact for less experienced endoscopists. Methods We performed a randomised tandem colonoscopy trial controlling for withdrawal time and bowel preparation. Average-risk adults undergoing screening colonoscopy were enrolled and randomly assigned to first withdrawal with one of the three imaging modalities (NBI (NBI-WL group), FICE (FICE-WL group) and WL (WL-WL group)). Eight colonoscopists were categorised into expert and non-expert subgroups. Results 1650 subjects (mean age 51.4 years, 63.9% men) were included (550 in each group). Compared with WL, neither NBI nor FICE increased the mean number of adenomas detected per patient (0.37 vs 0.35 and 0.36; p=0.591) or the percentage of patients with adenoma (25.3% vs 24.5% and 23.6%; p=0.753). For all three modalities, expert subgroups had higher yields of adenomas than non-expert subgroups. Learning curves were observed only for non-expert subgroups with all three modalities. The percentage of missed adenomas did not differ between the three groups (20.8% by WL vs 22.9% by NBI and 26.0% by FICE, p=0.300) and was not affected by endoscopists’ expertise. Conclusions Neither NBI nor FICE improved adenoma detection or miss rates, with no difference in diagnostic efficacy between the two systems. Virtual CE had no additional benefits over WL for non-experts. Clinical trial registration number: KCT0000570.Keywords
This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit:
- A randomized, controlled trial of narrow‐band imaging vs high‐definition white light for adenoma detection in patients at high risk of adenomasColorectal Disease, 2012
- The impact of narrow band imaging for colon polyp detection: a multicenter randomized controlled trial by tandem colonoscopyJournal of Gastroenterology, 2012
- Meta-analysis of narrow-band imaging versus conventional colonoscopy for adenoma detectionGastrointestinal Endoscopy, 2012
- Narrow-band imaging does not improve detection of colorectal polyps when compared to conventional colonoscopy: a randomized controlled trial and meta-analysis of published studiesBMC Gastroenterology, 2011
- Differentiating Small Polyp Histologies Using Real-Time Screening Colonoscopy With Fuji Intelligent Color EnhancementClinical Gastroenterology and Hepatology, 2011
- Efficacy of computed virtual chromoendoscopy on colorectal cancer screening: a prospective, randomized, back-to-back trial of Fuji Intelligent Color Enhancement versus conventional colonoscopy to compare adenoma miss ratesGastrointestinal Endoscopy, 2010
- Quality Indicators for Colonoscopy and the Risk of Interval CancerNew England Journal of Medicine, 2010
- A prospective comparative study of narrow-band imaging, chromoendoscopy, and conventional colonoscopy in the diagnosis of colorectal neoplasiaGut, 2006
- Quality Indicators for ColonoscopyAmerican Journal of Gastroenterology, 2006
- Polyp Miss Rate Determined by Tandem Colonoscopy: A Systematic ReviewAmerican Journal of Gastroenterology, 2006