Field Calibration for Corn of the Mehlich‐3 Soil Phosphorus Test with Colorimetric and Inductively Coupled Plasma Emission Spectroscopy Determination Methods
- 1 November 2003
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Soil Science Society of America Journal
- Vol. 67 (6) , 1928-1934
Abstract
Use of the Mehlich‐3 soil extractant with an inductively coupled plasma emission spectroscopy (ICP) determination method (M3‐ICP) is displacing the original colorimetry‐based test (M3‐COL). Current interpretations do not distinguish between these two versions, although the M3‐ICP test often measures more P. This study correlated these tests and the Bray‐P 1 (BP) test with corn ( Zea mays L.) yield response at 59 Iowa locations (78 site‐yr). The mean P measured by the M3‐ICP, M3‐COL, and BP tests was 31, 19, and 17 mg P kg −1 , respectively. The M3‐ICP/M3‐COL ratio decreased exponentially with increasing soil P ( P ≤ 0.01) but their difference was not correlated with soil P. Relative or absolute differences tended to decrease linearly ( P ≤ 0.01) with increasing soil pH or organic C, but the strength of the relationship was poor ( R 2 = 0.14–0.32). The BP test measured significantly less P in a CaCO 3 –affected soil (pH 8.1). The R 2 of the relationship between M3‐ICP and M3‐COL was 0.84, and was 0.89 between the M3‐COL and BP (0.97 excluding the site with pH 8.1). Critical concentrations defined by Cate‐Nelson and linear‐plateau models for the M3‐ICP, M3‐COL, and BP tests were 20 to 32, 16 to 21, and 13 to 20 mg kg −1 , respectively. The M3‐COL and M3‐ICP are equally effective for Iowa soils but interpretations differ. The M3‐ICP test should be considered a different test and its interpretations should be based on field calibrations rather than conversions based on M3‐COL data. A range of 25 to 35 mg kg −1 for the M3‐ICP test would correspond to the optimum class (16–20 mg kg −1 ) used in Iowa for the M3‐COL and BP tests.Keywords
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- An Agri‐Environmental Phosphorus Saturation Index for Acid Coarse‐Textured SoilsJournal of Environmental Quality, 2000
- Soil test methods: Past, present, and future use of soil extractantsCommunications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis, 1998
- Integrating the mehlich‐3 extractant into existing soil test interpretation schemesCommunications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis, 1996
- Comparison of different methods for determination of phosphorus in calcium chloride extracts for prediction of availability to plantsCommunications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis, 1995
- Advances in soil testing and plant analysis analytical technologyCommunications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis, 1990
- Comparison of field calibrations for mehlich 3 P and K with Bray‐Kurtz P1 and ammonium acetate K for cornCommunications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis, 1990
- Evaluation of Mehlich‐III extractant to estimate the available P in Quebec soilsCommunications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis, 1990
- Comparing Measurements of the Effect of Residual Fertilizer Phosphorus in Some Iowa SoilsSoil Science Society of America Journal, 1962
- A modified single solution method for the determination of phosphate in natural watersAnalytica Chimica Acta, 1962
- Evaluation of Residual Effects of Phosphate Fertilization by Laboratory and Plant‐Response MethodsSoil Science Society of America Journal, 1961