Collective Experimentation: Lessons from the Field
Author:
- 9 December 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Journal of Agricultural Education and Extension
- Vol. 15 (4) , 401-416
Abstract
The purpose of this paper is to document smallholder experiences during a participatory experimental initiative and draw useful lessons for field practitioners. The main methods used to collect data were participant observation, in-depth interviews among 40 farmers, and analyses of notes taken during participatory monitoring and evaluation. These farmers were regular participants in four collective trials—designed by scientists, managed by smallholders—that were run for over five years in western Kenya. This paper shows that scientific trial designs enhanced ‘conviction’ among smallholders in new technologies that were being experimented. The study further reveals that (1) collective trials must last long enough for interactive learning to effectively occur, (2) farmers’ selected aspects of experiments and did not generally treat the whole trial as one concept, (3) field trials were forms of evidence of research or project activity, and (4) trials were seen as like ‘churches’ and multipurpose congregating sites, especially because these collective experiments had roots in local traditions. The practical implication is that because interactive trials are social events, like other learning platforms, they must be appropriately situated within local contexts to enhance their relevance. This paper also shows that experiments are only a first step in learning, which needs to be supported by in-depth research and support for smallholder experiments. Collaborative experimentation is an effective tool for improving smallholder knowledge. Experimentation is a hands-on tool; it strengthens interactive learning, enhances understanding of a concept and improves ownership of the process or research among farmers. However, longer-term collective experiments develop a strong underlying human dimension. Understanding the social dynamics that influence the value of collective experimentation is critical for the process of scaling out.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- An ethnographic exploration of the impacts of HIV/AIDS on soil fertility management among smallholders in Butula, western KenyaNJAS: Wageningen Journal of Life Sciences, 2008
- Farmers and researchers: How can collaborative advantages be created in participatory research and technology development?Agriculture and Human Values, 2007
- WORKING WITH FARMERS: THE KEY TO ACHIEVING ADOPTION OF MORE SUSTAINABLE CASSAVA PRODUCTION PRACTICES ON SLOPING LAND IN ASIAActa Horticulturae, 2006
- Strengthening ‘folk ecology’: community-based learning for integrated soil fertility management, western KenyaInternational Journal of Agricultural Sustainability, 2006
- Facilitated learning in soil fertility management: assessing potentials of low-external-input technologies in east African farming systemsAgricultural Systems, 2004
- Agrarian Change and the Changing Relationships Between Toil and Soil in Maragoli, Western Kenya (1900–1994)Human Ecology, 2000
- Perceptions Regarding Adult Learners Motivation To Participate In Educational ProgramsJournal of Agricultural Education, 1999
- Facts, fantasies, and failures of farmer participatory researchAgriculture and Human Values, 1994
- Learning from six reasons why farmers do not adopt innovations intended to improve sustainability of upland agricultureAgricultural Systems, 1994
- Farmer Participatory Research1994