Exploring Structural Uncertainty and Impact of Health State Utility Values on Lifetime Outcomes in Diabetes Economic Simulation Models: Findings from the Ninth Mount Hood Diabetes Quality-of-Life Challenge
Open Access
- 15 December 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Medical Decision Making
- Vol. 42 (5) , 599-611
Abstract
Structural uncertainty can affect model-based economic simulation estimates and study conclusions. Unfortunately, unlike parameter uncertainty, relatively little is known about its magnitude of impact on life-years (LYs) and quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) in modeling of diabetes. We leveraged the Mount Hood Diabetes Challenge Network, a biennial conference attended by international diabetes modeling groups, to assess structural uncertainty in simulating QALYs in type 2 diabetes simulation models. Eleven type 2 diabetes simulation modeling groups participated in the 9th Mount Hood Diabetes Challenge. Modeling groups simulated 5 diabetes-related intervention profiles using predefined baseline characteristics and a standard utility value set for diabetes-related complications. LYs and QALYs were reported. Simulations were repeated using lower and upper limits of the 95% confidence intervals of utility inputs. Changes in LYs and QALYs from tested interventions were compared across models. Additional analyses were conducted postchallenge to investigate drivers of cross-model differences. Substantial cross-model variability in incremental LYs and QALYs was observed, particularly for HbA1c and body mass index (BMI) intervention profiles. For a 0.5%-point permanent HbA1c reduction, LY gains ranged from 0.050 to 0.750. For a 1-unit permanent BMI reduction, incremental QALYs varied from a small decrease in QALYs (−0.024) to an increase of 0.203. Changes in utility values of health states had a much smaller impact (to the hundredth of a decimal place) on incremental QALYs. Microsimulation models were found to generate a mean of 3.41 more LYs than cohort simulation models (P = 0.049). Variations in utility values contribute to a lesser extent than uncertainty captured as structural uncertainty. These findings reinforce the importance of assessing structural uncertainty thoroughly because the choice of model (or models) can influence study results, which can serve as evidence for resource allocation decisions.Keywords
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- Accounting for Methodological, Structural, and Parameter Uncertainty in Decision-Analytic ModelsMedical Decision Making, 2011
- Uncertainty and Patient Heterogeneity in Medical Decision ModelsMedical Decision Making, 2010
- Uncertainty and validation of health economic decision modelsHealth Economics, 2009
- Computer Modeling of Diabetes and Its ComplicationsDiabetes Care, 2007
- Impact of Model, Methodological, and Parameter Uncertainty in the Economic Analysis of Vaccination ProgramsMedical Decision Making, 2006
- ADVANCE—Action in Diabetes and Vascular Disease: patient recruitment and characteristics of the study population at baselineDiabetic Medicine, 2005
- Estimating Utility Values for Health States of Type 2 Diabetic Patients Using the EQ-5D (UKPDS 62)Medical Decision Making, 2002
- Panel 2: Methodological Issues in Conducting Pharmacoeconomic Evaluations—Modeling StudiesValue in Health, 1999
- Factors Associated With Avoidance of Severe Complications After 25 Yr of IDDM: Pittsburgh Epidemiology of Diabetes Complications Study IDiabetes Care, 1990
- Probabilistic Sensitivity Analysis Using Monte Carlo SimulationMedical Decision Making, 1985