This chapter examines Hans Lassen Martensen’s categorization of German medieval mysticism as “upbuilding religious popular-philosophy” in his 1840 monograph Meister Eckhart. Martensen’s repeated call to engage with the German mystics as a means for upbuilding has been overlooked and even explicitly denied in scholarship because of Martensen’s assessment that we must ultimately go beyond mysticism in order to gain objective knowledge. Exploring Martensen’s interpretation of mysticism as upbuilding philosophy will form the basis for considering Kierkegaard’s reception of Martensen’s Eckhart book and possible implicit engagement with Eckhart. It will be argued that Kierkegaard upholds Martensen’s view of mysticism as upbuilding philosophy, but defends mysticism from Martensen’s conclusion that speculative theology surpasses the subjective upbuilding popular-philosophical standpoint of mysticism. In addition, this chapter points out that Martensen and Kierkegaard share significant similarities in their respective engagements with mysticism as a form of upbuilding philosophy—more significant than they may have realized or cared to admit.