Poverty Matters: A Reassessment of the Inequality-Homicide Relationship in Cross-National Studies
Top Cited Papers
Open Access
- 1 April 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in The British Journal of Criminology
- Vol. 51 (5) , 739-772
Abstract
Dozens of cross-national studies of homicide have been published. Virtually all have reported an association between inequality and homicide, leading scholars to draw strong conclusions about this relationship. Unfortunately, each of these studies failed to control for poverty, even though poverty is the most consistent predictor of area homicide rates in the US empirical literature and a main confounder of the inequality–homicide association. The cross-national findings are also incongruent with US studies, which have yielded inconsistent results for the inequality–homicide association. In the present study, I replicated two prior studies in which a significant inequality–homicide association was found. After the original results were replicated, models that included a measure of poverty were estimated to see whether its inclusion had an impact on the inequality–homicide association. When effects for poverty and inequality were estimated in the same model, there was a positive and significant poverty–homicide association, while the inequality–homicide association disappeared in two of three models. These findings were consistent across different samples, data years, measures of inequality, dependent variables (overall and sex-specific homicide rates) and estimation procedures. The new results are congruent with what we know about poverty, inequality and homicide from the US empirical literature and suggest that the strong conclusions drawn about the inequality–homicide association may need to be reassessed, as the association may be a spurious result of model misspecification.Keywords
This publication has 51 references indexed in Scilit:
- Ascribed Economic Inequality and Homicide Among Modern SocietiesHomicide Studies, 2005
- Inequality and Violent CrimeThe Journal of Law and Economics, 2002
- Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct.American Psychologist, 2002
- The determinants of Infant Mortality in the Less Developed Countries: A Cross-National Test of Five TheoriesSocial Indicators Research, 2000
- Does Economic Growth Benefit the Masses? Growth, Dependence, and Welfare in the Third WorldAmerican Sociological Review, 1994
- Family Structure, Welfare Spending, and Child Homicide in Developed DemocraciesJournal of Marriage and Family, 1991
- DOES A DIFFERENCE MAKE A DIFFERENCE? COMPARING CROSS‐NATIONAL CRIME INDICATORS *Criminology, 1990
- POPULATION DIVERSITY AND CROSS‐NATIONAL HOMICIDE: THE EFFECTS OF INEQUALITY AND HETEROGENEITY*Criminology, 1986
- The Cost of Inequality: Metropolitan Structure and Violent CrimeAmerican Sociological Review, 1982
- THE EFFECT OF INCOME INEQUALITY AND SOCIAL DEMOCRACY ON HOMICIDEThe British Journal of Criminology, 1980