The effect of transparent unequal penalty rates on safety compliance for different-sized businesses
Open Access
- 13 January 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Behavioural Public Policy
- Vol. 9 (4) , 745-761
Abstract
The present study investigates the relation of procedural transparency and compliance with authorities’ regulations. The underlying assumption is that procedural transparency encourages compliance with regulations. In an incentivized experiment, 666 participants took on the role of a business owner and had to fill in a form and spend a certain amount of their income as compliance costs to adhere to safety rules. In a 2 (Business Size: small vs big) × 2 (Penalty Rate: equal vs unequal) × 2 (Penalty Scheme: transparent vs nontransparent) between-subjects design, we investigated whether an unequal penalty rate for small-size in contrast to big-size businesses had a different effect on compliance when this difference was transparent compared to when it was not transparent. Business income, compliance costs, and audit probability were varied within-subject, over 18 decision rounds. We find that the deterring effect of a higher penalty rate for big-size compared to small-size businesses under a nontransparent unequal penalty scheme is attenuated when the same information is available. This supports the idea of a backfiring effect and suggests that authorities need to carefully consider what information about their procedures to communicate in order to avoid the unintended negative effects of increasing transparency.Keywords
Funding Information
- Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy, UK Government
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- Job demands, job resources and safety outcomes: The roles of emotional exhaustion and safety complianceAccident Analysis & Prevention, 2013
- When do severe sanctions enhance compliance? The role of procedural fairnessJournal of Economic Psychology, 2011
- A field experiment to explore the effects of detection and penalties communications and framing among Washington State retail firmsAdvances in Accounting, 2010
- Factors influencing food safety management system adoption in Thai food‐manufacturing firmsBritish Food Journal, 2009
- Procedural justice in punishment systems: Inconsistent punishment procedures have detrimental effects on cooperationBritish Journal of Social Psychology, 2008
- Transparency, Democratic Accountability, and the Economic Consequences of Monetary InstitutionsAmerican Journal of Political Science, 2003
- Speaking to Theorists and Searching for Facts: Tax Morale and Tax Compliance in ExperimentsJournal of Economic Surveys, 2002
- Paths to Compliance: Enforcement, Management, and the European UnionInternational Organization, 2002
- Pressure, Opportunity and Predisposition: A Multivariate Model of Corporate IllegalityJournal of Management, 1994
- Toward an Integrated Theory of White-Collar CrimeAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1987