Ethicist as Designer: A Pragmatic Approach to Ethics in the Lab
- 20 November 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Science and Engineering Ethics
- Vol. 20 (4) , 947-961
Abstract
Contemporary literature investigating the significant impact of technology on our lives leads many to conclude that ethics must be a part of the discussion at an earlier stage in the design process i.e., before a commercial product is developed and introduced. The problem, however, is the question regarding how ethics can be incorporated into an earlier stage of technological development and it is this question that we argue has not yet been answered adequately. There is no consensus amongst scholars as to the kind of ethics that should be practiced, nor the individual selected to perform this ethical analysis. One school of thought holds that ethics should have pragmatic value in research and design and that it should be implemented by the (computer) engineers and/or (computer) scientists themselves, while another school of thought holds that ethics need not be so pragmatic. For the latter, the ethical reflection can aim at a variety of goals, and be carried out by an ethicist. None of the approaches resulting from these lines of thinking have been adopted on a wide-scale basis. To that end, the approach presented here is intended to bridge the gap between these schools of thought. It is our contention that ethics ought to be pragmatic and to provide utility for the design process and we maintain that adequate ethical reflection, and all that it entails, ought to be conducted by an ethicist. Thus, we propose a novel role for the ethicist—the ethicist as designer—who subscribes to a pragmatic view of ethics in order to bring ethics into the research and design of artifacts—no matter the stage of development. In this paper we outline the series of steps that a pragmatic value analysis entails: uncovering relevant values, scrutinizing these values and, working towards the translation of values into technical content. In conclusion, we present a list of tasks for the ethicist in his/her role as designer on the interdisciplinary team.Keywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- Designing Robots for Care: Care Centered Value-Sensitive DesignScience and Engineering Ethics, 2012
- “But the data is already public”: on the ethics of research in FacebookEthics and Information Technology, 2010
- What Values in Design? The Challenge of Incorporating Moral Values into DesignScience and Engineering Ethics, 2010
- Parallel, Embedded or Just Part of the Team: Ethicists Cooperating Within a European Security Research ProjectScience and Engineering Ethics, 2009
- Defining PrivacyJournal of Social Philosophy, 2008
- Imagining the Future of Photoacoustic MammographyScience and Engineering Ethics, 2008
- Ethnographic Invention: Probing the Capacity of Laboratory DecisionsNanoEthics, 2007
- Design and use as plans: an action-theoretical accountDesign Studies, 2002
- Disclosive computer ethicsACM SIGCAS Computers and Society, 2000
- Information Privacy: Measuring Individuals’ Concerns About Organizational Practices1MIS Quarterly, 1996