Background and Objective:Virtual surgical planning (VSP) improves geometric accuracy in mandibular reconstruction; however, intraoperative deviations from the planned geometry are frequently unavoidable. Such deviations can alter load transfer pathways and structural configuration, yet their biomechanical consequences, particularly in relation to plate overloading and failure, remain poorly understood. Establishing a mechanistic link between geometry variation and implant stress is therefore critical but has not been systematically investigated in clinically relevant scenarios.Methods: This numerical study was based on a clinical case of postoperative titanium plate fracture following fibula free flap mandibular reconstruction. Four FE models were analysed under standardised 50 N masticatory loading at four sites (molar, incisor, fibula segment 1, fibula segment 2): the original VSP model, the actual postoperative 3-segment construct with an interposed middle bone wedge, a theoretical 2-segment construct without the wedge, and a theoretical 4-segment construct with an additional posterior wedge. Von Mises (VM) stress distribution and peak plate stress were compared across all configurations. Extended finite element method (XFEM) analysis was performed under the two most critical loading scenarios to assess crack initiation and propagation.Results: Relative to the VSP model, with peak VM stress of 40–65 MPa, the postoperative 3-segment construct demonstrated anterior translation of stress concentration and substantially higher peak plate stress under all loading scenarios, with increases of 124–284 MPa depending on loading site. Stress concentration in the 3-segment construct colocalised with the clinically observed fracture site. Removing the middle wedge alone did not consistently reduce peak stress, whereas adding a posterior wedge reduced peak plate stress by 47–121 MPa relative to the 3-segment construct and redistributed stress concentration away from a single recurrent site. XFEM predicted crack initiation at the clinically observed fracture site under molar loading, and showed the most extensive crack propagation in the 2-segment construct.Conclusions: In this patient-specific analysis, isolated filling of the middle intersegmental gap did not mitigate plate overloading, whereas restoring bone contact at both gaps improved load sharing and reduced peak plate stress, and limited crack propagation. These findings support the potential use of FE analysis as a case-specific adjunct for evaluating major deviations from VSP.