As the insect mass-rearing industry is expected to grow, residual streams are expected to become increasingly available. Before these residues can be used as organic amendments, more knowledge of the dynamics of decomposition and the microbial communities involved is needed. This study investigated the decomposition, N-mineralization, and fungal/bacterial community composition during 16 weeks of incubation of exuviae and frass of BSF, mealworm, and house cricket in pots containing arable soil. The decomposition of insect residues in litterbags was rapid, with more than 50% weight loss over two weeks. The release of mineral-N from dispersed insect materials was also the highest during the first two weeks, but was more profound for soils treated with exuviae than their frass counterparts. Soil amendment with insect residues enriched chitinolytic soil microbial inhabitants belonging to Gammaproteobacteria, Bacilli, Actinobacteria, and Mortierellomycetes. Comparison of soil amendments with sterilized and non-sterilized mealworm exuviae showed that the presence of microbial propagules had a negligible influence on the composition of bacterial decomposers, but the impact on the fungal community was significant. Our results reveal that amendments with insect residues have a good prospect of increasing natural biocontrol via stimulation of microbial antagonists of plant-pathogenic fungi and could become a tool for integration into soil-borne disease management strategies.