One of the main challenges faced by any manufacturing company is controlling the quality of its products. The complexity of the issue intensifies when quality variables are not only quantitative but also qualitative, which means that decisions related to product quality largely depend on subjective assessments made by experts. This research designed a decision-making control chart for a multidisciplinary quality control system in a tannery company, with the goal of improving product quality in the “Wet Sole” area. The main quality issues were associated with qualitative variables and the lack of standardization in the criteria for making quality-related decisions, which increased dissatisfaction with the final product. The problem was addressed with the support of experts, who mapped the “Wet Sole” area process to identify subprocesses and the quantitative and qualitative variables associated with product quality. Then, through the Analytic Hierarchy Process, operating–quality–decision intervals were defined, which enabled the construction of “decision-making control charts.” These charts became part of the new quality control system. The system was validated by experts, confirming its accuracy and effectiveness in decision-making. Once implemented, the evaluation criteria for quality were standardized within the process, resulting in a significant improvement in product quality.