Enhancing Silvicultural Practices: A Productivity and Quality Comparison of Manual and Semi-Mechanized Planting Methods in KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa
Open Access
Abstract
Planting plays a significant role in commercial forestry. Labour-related issues (scarcity, increased wages, absenteeism, ageing and high turnover), inconsistent work quality, increased operational costs, and poor ergonomics prompted the development of innovative planting techniques. This study aimed to assess the productivity (plants/productive machine hour), worker productivity (plants/worker PMH), work quality and tree survival of a manual and a semi-mechanised planting method. Two study sites at Flatcrown and Kwambonambi, consisting of 37 plots, were planted at 1333 stems/ha, alternating across the study sites. Block-level and elemental-level time studies were conducted, followed by work quality assessments. The manual method planted 7.23 ha/shift (Flatcrown) and 5.89 ha/shift (Kwambonambi), whilst the semi-mechanised method planted 4.72 ha/shift (Flatcrown) and 3.19 ha/shift (Kwambonambi). The manual method was 50% to 60% more productive (plants/PMH) than the semi-mechanised method. In terms of plants/worker PMH, higher worker efficiency of 30%–40% was observed at the Flatcrown site, which was characterised by level terrain and low residue presence compared to the Kwambonambi site, which had a gentle (<20%) terrain and medium residue presence. Planting quality was conducted according to planting specifications. The two methods did not significantly differ, although the study suggests that the proportion of good-quality plantings could be somewhat higher for the manual method. There was no significant difference in tree survival across methods and sites after one month.Keywords
All Related Versions
Funding Information
- National Research Foundation (TTK2204102921, FW/BUR/2023-2024/022140.01, 11827)
- Fibre processing & manufacturing (FP&M) SETA (TTK2204102921, FW/BUR/2023-2024/022140.01, 11827)
- Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University (TTK2204102921, FW/BUR/2023-2024/022140.01, 11827)
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Cost-efficiency and ergonomic study of two methods for planting Eucalyptus spp. seedlings in plantation forestrySilva Fennica, 2021
- Advances in the Mechanization of Regenerating Plantation Forests: a ReviewCurrent Forestry Reports, 2020
- Effect of soil preparation method on root development of P. sylvestris and P. abies saplings in commercial forest standsNew Forests, 2018
- Mechanized tree planting in Finland and improving its productivityDissertationes Forestales, 2017
- Deep planting decreases risk of drought damage and increases growth of Norway spruce container seedlingsNew Forests, 2016
- Changes in planted forests and future global implicationsForest Ecology and Management, 2015
- Comparative study of the Risutec Automatic Plant Container (APC) and Bracke planting devicesSilva Fennica, 2014
- Competitiveness of mechanized tree planting in FinlandScandinavian Journal of Forest Research, 2013
- Machine planting of Norway spruce by Bracke and Ecoplanter: an evaluation of soil preparation, planting method and seedling performanceSilva Fennica, 2011
- The effect of land preparation at re-establishment on the productivity of fast growing hardwoods in South AfricaAustralian Forestry, 2001