Replicability of Scientific Claims in Drosophila Immunity: A Retrospective Analysis of 400 Publications
Preprint
- 8 October 2026
- preprint
- Published by eLife Sciences Publications, Ltd in eLife preprints
- Vol. 15
Abstract
Drosophila immunity has been the focus of intense study and has impacted other research fields including innate immunity and agriculturally or epidemiologically relevant investigations of insect pests and vectors. Unsurprisingly for such a large body of work, some published results were later found to be irreplicable. Although some results have been contradicted in the literature, many have no published follow-up, either due to a lack of research or low motivation to publish negative or contradictory results. We have addressed this by performing a reproducibility project that analyses the conceptual replicability of claims from articles published on Drosophila immunity before 2011. To assess replicability, we extracted claims from 400 articles on the Drosophila immune response to bacteria and fungi and performed preliminary verification by comparing these claims to other published literature in the field. Using alternative approaches, we also experimentally tested some ‘unchallenged’ claims, with no published follow-up. The intent of this analysis was to centralize evidence on insights and findings to improve clarity for scientists that may base research programs on these data. Although the aim of the ReproSci project is to assess the replicability of claims made in articles published in the field of Drosophila immunity, it is in no way an assessment of the ‘scientific value’ of the research. All our data are published on a publicly available website associated with this article (https://ReproSci.epfl.ch/) that encourages community participation. This article provides a short summary of claims that were found to have contradictory evidence, which may help the community to assess past findings on Drosophila immunity and improve clarity going forward. Statistical analysis of this reproducibility study and metascience insights obtained from this approach are discussed in a companion article.Keywords
Funding Information
- Schweizerischer Nationalfonds zur Förderung der Wissenschaftlichen Forschung (310030_189085)
- ETH Domain Open Research Data Program
This publication has 160 references indexed in Scilit:
- Exploring new perspectives in immunologyCell, 2024
- Sensing microbial infections in the Drosophila melanogaster genetic model organismImmunogenetics, 2022
- Methods for the study of innate immunity in Drosophila melanogasterWIREs Developmental Biology, 2019
- Corpse Engulfment Generates a Molecular Memory that Primes the Macrophage Inflammatory ResponseCell, 2016
- Undertaker, a Drosophila Junctophilin, Links Draper-Mediated Phagocytosis and Calcium HomeostasisCell, 2008
- Dual Detection of Fungal Infections in Drosophila via Recognition of Glucans and Sensing of Virulence FactorsCell, 2006
- The evolution of immune mechanismsJournal of Experimental Zoology Part B: Molecular and Developmental Evolution, 2006
- The serine protease Sp7 is expressed in blood cells and regulates the melanization reaction in DrosophilaBiochemical and Biophysical Research Communications, 2005
- Eater, a Transmembrane Protein Mediating Phagocytosis of Bacterial Pathogens in DrosophilaCell, 2005
- Postembryonic Hematopoiesis in DrosophilaDevelopmental Biology, 2001