The European Commission’s Regulatory Proposal on New Genomic Techniques in Plants: A Focus on Equivalence, Complexity, and Artificial Intelligence
Preprint
- 3 September 2025
- preprint
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Abstract
The European Commission has proposed to amend the EU GMO regulation, exempting certain genetically modified plants generated with new genomic techniques (NGTs) from risk assessment. In the suggested lex specialis so-called “category 1 NGT plants” would be treated as equivalent to conventionally bred plants, if they meet threshold-based criteria, which limit the number and size of induced genetic changes. Here, we critically analyze the scientific validity of these thresholds and show that the proposal oversimplifies genetic complexity – disregarding the biological context, mutational bias, and functional consequences. The proposal’s central claim of equivalence between NGT1 plants and conventionally bred plants is thus scientifically unfounded. Many conceivable genetic modifications produced with NGTs – including those created with CRISPR prime editing and AI-assisted design – could be highly complex and exceed the capabilities of conventional breeding. Nevertheless, the regulatory proposal treats all possible genetic changes as equally likely and overlooks the purpose and function of genetic edits. By eliminating case-by-case risk assessment, the proposal creates a regulatory gap that allows complex and novel traits to bypass scrutiny – undermining the EU’s legally binding precautionary principle. In contrast, a risk-based regulatory approach is needed to ensure safe and future-proof oversight of NGT plants.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- Synthetic biology and artificial intelligence in crop improvementPlant Communications, 2024
- Generative artificial intelligence for de novo protein designCurrent Opinion in Structural Biology, 2024
- The applications of CRISPR/Cas-mediated microRNA and lncRNA editing in plant biology: shaping the future of plant non-coding RNA researchPlanta, 2023
- CRISPR/Cas-mediated plant genome editing: outstanding challenges a decade after implementationTrends in Plant Science, 2023
- Exploring impact of recombination landscapes on breeding outcomesProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2023
- Prime editing-mediated precise knockin of protein tag sequences in the rice genomePlant Communications, 2023
- Designing artificial synthetic promoters for accurate, smart, and versatile gene expression in plantsPlant Communications, 2023
- Evolution of recombination landscapes in diverging populations of bread wheatGenome Biology and Evolution, 2021
- INDEL detection, the ‘Achilles heel’ of precise genome editing: a survey of methods for accurate profiling of gene editing induced indelsNucleic Acids Research, 2020
- The coming of age of de novo protein designNature, 2016