Genetic evaluation with uncertain parentage: a comparison of methods
Authors:
- 1 June 1992
- journal article
- Published by Springer Nature in Theoretical and Applied Genetics
- Vol. 84 (1-2) , 173-179
Abstract
The most common method for genetic evaluation when parents are unknown is best linear unbiased prediction with genetic groups (BLUP-G). With this method unknown parents are assumed to be unrelated to any other animals in the population. This assumption is unrealistic in most situations. If a finite number of potential parents can be identified and the probabilities of being the true parent can be assigned to these, genetic evaluation can be obtained given the uncertainty of parentage without introducing genetic groups into the model. The correct numerator relationship matrix with uncertain parentage (Ā) is derived. Rules are given to efficiently compute Ā and Ā-1. Computer simulation was used to compare BLUP-G with BLUP using Ā. The simulated population consisted of ten sires and 200 dams per breeding season. The dams were always known; the sires were unknown for 10% or 30% of the males and 30% of the females. The number of potential sires was three (BLUP-Ā1 or ten (BLUP-Ā2), including the true sire in both cases. Equal probabilities were assigned to each potential sire. The increase in response with BLUP-Ā1 and BLUP-Ā2 relative to BLUP-G ranged from 4% to 8% in the fifth breeding season. Selection with BLUP-Ā1 or BLUP-Ā2 resulted in higher inbreeding, 17% and 12%, respectively, than with BLUP-G. Estimates of response to selection were unbiased with BLUP-Ā1 and BLUP-Ā2, but not unbiased with BLUP-G. Mean square error of estimated genetic means and mean prediction error variance were higher with BLUP-G than with blup-Ā1 or BLUP-Ā2.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- On the principle underlying the tabular method to compute coancestryTheoretical and Applied Genetics, 1991
- Problems in the Use of the Relationship Matrix in Animal Breeding1990
- Additive Genetic Model with Groups and RelationshipsJournal of Dairy Science, 1988
- Use of an Average Numerator Relationship Matrix for Multiple-Sire JoiningJournal of Animal Science, 1988
- Indirect Solution of Mixed Model EquationsJournal of Dairy Science, 1987
- Sire evaluation with uncertain paternityGenetics Selection Evolution, 1987
- Estimation of Response to Selection Using Least-Squares and Mixed Model MethodologyJournal of Animal Science, 1984
- Estimation de la valeur génétique des reproducteurs dans les cas d'incertitude sur les apparentements I. Formulation des indices de sélectionGenetics Selection Evolution, 1984
- A Simple Method for Computing the Inverse of a Numerator Relationship Matrix Used in Prediction of Breeding ValuesBiometrics, 1976
- Inbreeding in artificial selection programmesGenetics Research, 1961